Sandra Finley

Nov 292009
 

CHRONOLOGY (CONTEXT) FOR UNDERSTANDING HOW MORE MONEY WILL BE TRANSFERRED FROM THE GOVERNMENT TO THE NUCLEAR/URANIUM INDUSTRY.  THE UNIVERSITY IS THE MIDDLE MAN.

The following chronology is an aid to understanding the November 30th decision of the “Expert Review Panel”.  It creates CONTEXT.

It is just a sampling of evidence from the public record.   Some of you will add your own information to it.

I want to get this chronology out prior to the announcement of the decision of the panel, in case it might be useful.  Please consider forwarding it to media people you might know, as background.

I will send supporting news reports for the chronology later; don’t want to overload you with email today!   /Sandra

– – – – – – – – – – – – – –

EXPERT REVIEW PANEL

DECISION ON FEDERAL FUNDING FOR ISOTOPE PRODUCTION AND

UNIVERSITY OF SASKATCHEWAN’S PROPOSAL FOR A SMALL NUCLEAR REACTOR.

FOR CANADIAN DEMOCRACY AND TAX-PAYERS

PUSH FOR NUCLEAR/URANIUM AGENDA REVEALED BY CHRONOLOGY:

• 1974, India broke the International Nuclear Non-Proliferation treaty by building & testing a nuclear bomb made using Canadian nuclear technology.

• 1976, Eldorado Nuclear planned to build a uranium refinery near Warman, SK. The NDP Government of the day wanted to “add value” to the uranium resource by refining milled yellow-cake into fuel for nuclear reactors.  Citizen opposition coalesced.

•  In 1980, Premier Bill Bennett bowed to public pressure and introduced a seven-year moratorium on uranium mining and exploration in B.C.    The moratorium remains in place.  The moratorium was based on the evidence of the health consequences.  The successful efforts to get the moratorium were largely the work of one doctor, Bob Woollard.

•  In 1981, after 5 years of intense citizen efforts (more than 500 people) Eldorado announced it was withdrawing its bid to build a refinery in Saskatchewan.

•  In 1981 Nova Scotia placed a moratorium on uranium mining.  (See Oct 2009, the N.S. moratorium becomes entrenched in law.)

•  1987, Manitoba passed a law to prohibit high level radioactive waste disposal in its territory.

• November  2007, Saskatchewan Party (conservative) elected.  Nuclear/uranium agenda not in its platform.

• March 2008,  Alberta signs agreement with Idaho National Laboratory, the U.S. Department of Energy’s leading institution for nuclear energy research.  “Marriage made in heaven”.   http://www2.canada.com/edmontonjournal/news/cityplus/story.html?id=1556f1f1-24a3-4276-945d-1d60a965b153&p=1 (In case this Edmonton Journal link becomes invalid,  the article is posted at   2008-03-29 Alberta with Idaho National Laboratory to study nuclear role in oilsands.)

• March 2008,  Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall in Washington “promoting the province as a secure source of energy, including oil, gas, uranium and, potentially, oilsands”.

• March 28, 2008.  Leader Post reports on Brad Wall’s “big plans” for nuclear power in Saskatchewan, following “lengthy discussion” he had with Stephen Harper.   http://www.canada.com/reginaleaderpost/news/story.html?id=eb5b2b4d-77d3-41d1-b060-18c6c9ca9c44 (The article is copied at http://sandrafinley.ca/?p=6340 )

• July 04 2008.  “New Brunswick introduces new regulations on uranium mining”

“GOVERNMENT TRIES TO MUTE CALLS FOR A MORATORIUM

The Telegraph-Journal reports, ” In an effort to mute calls for a moratorium on uranium exploration, the government announced in May much tighter regulations that included returning all radioactive materials to drill holes sealed with a clay-like substance called bentonite; testing water wells within 500 metres of a drill site before and after work is done; and keeping liquid waste from drilling operations a safe distance from wetlands. But that failed to quell the public uproar. Recent information sessions with concerned landowners in Fredericton and Moncton turned into boisterous protests, with citizens railing passionately against uranium exploration.”

• Nov 5, 2008  Obama elected President of the U.S.

• Feb 27, 2009  “Work on disposing of radioactive waste at Yucca Mountain (Nevada) has all but stopped after President Barack Obama’s budget blueprint.  The move remains in line with Obama’s pre-election statements that Yucca Mountain was “not an option.”  America must now set a new course for long-term management of high-level radioactive waste, ….

“Obama’s position on the Global Nuclear Energy Partnership (GNEP), which would see a community of countries share nuclear power technology with leading nations storing all the high-level waste from the entire group…

“Modern long-term strategies usually involve a step-wise reversible process that starts with an invitation to communities nationwide to express interest.”

(Precisely the process that is being used by the Nuclear Waste Management Organization (NWMO) in Canada.  Saskatchewan is a targeted site.  The NWMO met in Saskatoon in Sept – see the chronology.  And will be here again in December – see chronology.)

• March 2009, the Government of Saskatchewan Uranium Development Partnership (UDP) Panel chaired by Richard Florizone, Vice-President of the University, recommended that Saskatchewan develop nuclear power, create a nuclear waste dump and a studies centre of excellence at the University of Saskatchewan.  With respect to radioactive isotopes it said:   “the economics of a stand-alone isotope reactor are not attractive

a reactor to do research and development that “is synergetic” with the larger nuclear expansion plan “may also be used to produce medical isotopes…to partly offset the cost of developing and operating the reactor.”

It suggests this “could justify further funding from federal authorities.”

• March 17, 2009  Energy and Resources Minister Bill Boyd and Enterprise and Innovation Minister Lyle Stewart signed a Memorandum of Understanding between the government and Idaho National Laboratory (INL), a U.S. Department of Energy institution that is considered that country’s top national laboratory for nuclear energy research.

• April 2009,  “Experts examining Areva’s cash situation just days before its accounts are published show that it is “staring down the barrel of business failure” with a 3 billion Euro bail-out request from the French Government. Overrun costs of its reactor build in Finland have left the project facing a 5.4 billion Euro bill including an invoice to Areva of 2.4 billion Euros in penalties for lateness amounting to over three years. Embarrasingly for Areva, German engineering partner Siemans recently walked away from the project.

• Meanwhile in Saskatchewan, growing public concern about UDP industry-one-sidedness left the Sask Party government with no political alternative but to undertake a “public consultation process”

• May 2009 Public Consultations began.  Dan Perrins conducted the consultations.  2,637 people in total attended thirteen public meetings.  1,275 written submissions and 61 stakeholder groups presented,  2,263 responses in total.

• 84% of the submissions were opposed to nuclear power, in spite of a letter-writing campaign by the nuclear industry and the Chamber of Commerce.

• Energy and Resources Minister Bill Boyd called it “the broadest and most transparent public debate on uranium development ever undertaken in Saskatchewan”.

• June 15, “Spearheaded by Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall and Montana Governor Brian Schweitzer“   “hailed their push to develop a cross-border (Canada – U.S.) Western Energy Corridor that will be the largest on the planet and one that develops both non-renewable (tar sands) and clean-energy (nuclear) options.”

This news report was in the middle of the “public consultations”, on the same day as approximately 800 people turned out to the Saskatoon meeting.  The Travelodge had to extend the meeting room which filled to standing room only.  Some people did not attend because parking was not to be found.

• June 2009, Point le Preau nuclear reactor in New Brunswick – “The $1.4-billion refurbishment of the Point Lepreau nuclear plant has fallen behind schedule. . . That delay will cost NB Power an estimated $70 million to $90 million.  Ottawa gives $200 million in extra funding to AECL.  “This amounts to more subsidies to a nuclear white elephant”.   (Around the time of this news article, James Risdon in New Brunswick started  “Say NO to Nuclear Waste in N.B.! “ – on The Petition Site.”)

• June 19,  Federal Government announces four Expert Review Panel Members and call for expressions of interest in isotope production.

http://www.nrcan-rncan.gc.ca/media/newcom/2009/200962-eng.php

Thom Mason, Director of the Oak Ridge National Laboratory in Tennessee, part of the U.S. Department of Energy is a panel member.

http://www.ornl.gov/ornlhome/leadership/mason_bio.shtml

• July 9, 2009  REACTOR PARTNERSHIP REACHED : GOVT, U OF S TO PURSUE MEDICAL ISOTOPE PRODUCTION

(link no longer valid, Star Phoenix.  Did I post a back-up copy? Look.)

•  June 14, 2009.  Canada-U.S. Western Energy Corridor announced.

(link no longer valid, Vancouver Sun.  I think I posted a copy on this blog.  Look.)

Western premiers and U.S. governors on Sunday hailed their push to develop a cross-border Western Energy Corridor that will be the largest on the planet and one that develops both non-renewable (INSERT: tar sands) and clean-energy (INSERT: nuclear) options. …

Spearheaded by Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall and Montana Governor Brian Schweitzer … ”

• July 17, The On Campus News says  “Nuclear studies centre already under development” …  working at various points in the nuclear cycle, … that extends from exploration and mining to power production to safe storage” (radioactive waste disposal).    (Link no longer valid.  Sandra – – find and post the article.)

• July 2009, “First time ever University Presidents  join Government and Corporate leaders, Canada – U.S.”

(Link no longer valid.  Did I post a copy on this blog?    http://news.prnewswire.com/DisplayReleaseContent.aspx?ACCT=104&STORY=/www/story/07-08-2009/0005056956&EDATE=)

“Other highlights:

–   University President’s Roundtable – first time ever University Presidents from both the US and Canada will meet to discuss Innovation and collaboration in the region (15 University Presidents will be in attendance) . .

–   First Energy Horizon Legislative Institute.  30 Legislators from throughout the Region to be certified on Energy Policy by University of Idaho, PNWER, and National Conference of State Legislators.

(INSERT:  I looked this up.  The Idaho National Laboratory, with which Saskatchewan and Alberta have signed deals, is at the University of Idaho.  The “certification” process “educates” legislators on the “energy” question, a la Americano.)

–  Water Policy to focus on water management policies and overview of the Columbia River Treaty . . .

–  Admiral John Grossenbacher, Idaho National Laboratory, will chair a session led by INL on emerging regional interests in nuclear energy, western energy corridor …

–  Building Transmission for the future – Session to address regional transmission projects  (high power transmission lines)

• July 31, 2009 federal deadline for applications for funding related to radioactive isotopes. The Government of Saskatchewan (Brad Wall) Crown Investments Corporation jointly with the University of Saskatchewan applied:

“recommending establishing a national nuclear studies centre of excellence at the university. .. will include building a nuclear research reactor for both isotope production and neutron science.”      “Targets 2016 for reactor to be online”

• July 31, 2009. The deadline for citizens to respond to the Government’s Uranium Development Partnership (UDP) report (public consultation process on the Government’s nuclear/uranium agenda).

• September 15,   Dan Perrins delivered his report on the public consultations to Wall’s government.  The Executive Summary says, “the overwhelming response was that nuclear power generation should not be a choice for Saskatchewan.”

Regarding other recommendations of the UDP Report, Perrins reported  “the majority of responses dealing with the exploration and mining of uranium did not support current or future activities in this area.”

The majority “are largely opposed to any upgrading, including enrichment fuel fabrication and all other forms of upgrading.”.

Many people who expressed support for the production of medical isotopes stipulated it should occur without the use of nuclear fission.”

• October 2009,  String of incidents, several incidents of “exceedances” and spills, prompts investigation at Cameco Port Hope conversion plant.

• October 4, 2009.  “No nukes, go Renewables” parade and rally in Saskatoon draws people from around the province.

• October 14, 2009.  Nova Scotia legislates a moratorium on exploration and mining of uranium. http://www.gov.ns.ca/news/details.asp?id=20091014006

“The province introduced legislation today, Oct. 14, to entrench a uranium ban that had been in effect since 1981.”

• October 2009, Speech from the Throne Government of Saskatchewan contains no mention of the Government’s nuclear/uranium agenda.

• October 2009, Book launch “Selling Out, Academic Freedom and the Corporate Market”, McGill-Queen’s University Press, by Howard Woodhouse, professor of educational foundations and co-director of the University of Saskatchewan Process Philosophy Research Unit.

Page 166:  (Bancroft is interim director of the Canadian Light Source Inc (synchrotron) at the University of Saskatchewan) “Bancroft’s emphasis on the CLS’s “strong commitment to industrial users and private/public partnerships, [with] designated Canadian and international mining companies as the top priority for industrial development” was consistent with the facility’s mission.

(Note:  the supporting news reports in the next emails clearly make the connection between the synchrotron at the University of Saskatchewan and the nuclear/uranium agenda.)

P. 165 “Yet the CLS . . . was paid for almost entirely out of public funds from the federal and provincial governments, several universities, and a Saskatchewan Crown corporation.  The capital costs of $173.5 million were split into $140.9 million in cash and $32.6 million in in-kind contributions

(see table). . . .  Moreover this amount does not include the in-kind contribution of the university’s Linear Accelerator, worth almost $33 million …  By far the largest amount of money came from the federal government – – “  etc.

• (?? I don’t know if this should be included) November 4, 2009  Fortune Minerals Metallurgical processing plant near Saskatoon.

(Link no longer valid  http://www.thestarphoenix.com/Refinery+planned+Langham/2181681/story.html)

This is a “maybe” connection. The background is that the nuclear/uranium industry in Canada is facing problems with processing and conversion capacity. It is running into more and more public opposition.  The Port Hope refinery is under assault for effects on health and the release of radioactive spills into Lake Ontario, etc. (other examples).

Regarding the Star Phoenix refinery announcement November 4, it was curious to me that a penny stock company, Fortune Minerals, would truck ore all the way from Yellowknife, N.W.T. to Saskatoon, SK for “metallurgical processing”.

I wonder whether such a processing facility might also be used for uranium?  Given the stated priorities for the University of Saskatchewan’s synchrotron, the Canadian Nuclear Studies Centre at the University and the University’s commitment to work that has commercial application it seems plausible.

It seems to me that the nuclear/uranium corporations (with their Government, University supporters and role in the U.S. corporate energy strategy (the SPP)) are hard-pressed now to be honest and forthright about their intentions.

• Nov 15   Stephen Harper, salesman for the co-dependent nuclear and tar sands industries, in India.   “Canada had suspended nuclear relations with India in 1974 after India used Canadian technology to make its first nuclear bomb.  During his visit here, Harper said a new nuclear co-operation deal between the two countries would be signed soon and he met with key representatives of India’s nuclear energy sector.”  India has not signed the nuclear non-proliferation treaty.

“The two countries signed a memorandum of understanding this year that will let Canada play a role in India’s planned building of 25 to 30 nuclear reactors. …  India’s reactor demand for uranium may triple in the next 15 years, according to Saskatoon, Saskatchewan-based Cameco Corp. the world’s second-largest producer of uranium.  . . .

Australia, holder of the biggest known uranium reserves, doesn’t allow exports of the nuclear fuel to India because the South Asian country hasn’t signed the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. ”

• November 29, 2009.  “Prime Minister Stephen Harper of Canada signs a nuclear co-operation agreement with Indian Prime Minister Manmohan as way to trade uranium and nuclear technology with India”  . . .  on whose behalf?   (Link no longer valid  http://trak.in/news/india-canada-clinch-nuclear-deal/29084/)

• NWMO (Nuclear Waste Management Organization) in Saskatchewan (again!) December 7, 8, 9, looking for a “host community”.

http://www.nwmo.ca/events?event

– – – – – – – – – – –

Note:  I have not included the propaganda efforts by Bruce Power in the North Saskatchewan River corridor where they want to buy options on land for a nuclear reactor, or the polling reported on in the Prince Albert Herald and elsewhere.  The polling questions were designed to manipulate and provide very skewed results.

I have not included efforts by Bruce Power and by the Nuclear Waste Management Organization to target First Nations, Dene and Metis communities for the siting of their operations.

Nor have I mentioned the resistance by motley crews of local groups.  (These efforts by local people to stop a Bruce Power nuclear reactor from being built on the North Saskatchewan River appear to have been successful, so far.)

I have not mentioned the efforts of people in Alberta to stop the billion-dollar high power transmission lines (part of the Canada – U.S. Western Energy Corridor) from proceeding.

Nor a whole lot of other important events!    /Sandra

Nov 192009
 

This email is about infectious disease (H1N1 example) and the pharmaceutical corporations.

You can interchange the phrases:

– “pharmaceutical corporations”

– “nuclear/uranium corporations”

– “the oil and gas corporations”,

– “the arms manufacturers” (Lockheed Martin example at Dalhousie University)

etc.

They are all “on-campus”.  The lessons are the same, regardless of the industry.  This one is a pharmaceutical corporation example.  The issue is larger than H1N1.

CONTENTS

(1) GARY NULL ADDRESSES NEW YORK STATE HEARING, H1N1 VACCINATIONS (YouTube)

(2) IS GARY NULL A “QUACK”?  WHICH DOCTORS ARE TRAINED AND OBEDIENT TO “MEDI”CARE?  WHICH ONES TAKE MONEY, TRIPS AND LARGESSE FOR SPEAKING ENGAGEMENTS FROM THE PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY?

(3) ARTHUR SCHAFER, ETHICIST, ON THE SWINE FLU

(4) MEDICARE DEALS IN DRUGS, NOT IN IMMUNE SYSTEMS

(5)  UPDATE ON NIGERIAN GOVERNMENT COURT CASE AGAINST PFIZER OVER DRUG TRIALS THAT KILLED PEOPLE.

(6)  THE CONSTANT GARDENER.  VIDO (VACCINE INFECTIOUS DISEASES ORGANIZATION) AT THE UNIVERSITY OF SASKATCHEWAN.

(7) “SELLING OUT”, THE OLIVIERI STORY AND THE SYNCHROTRON RELATED TO H1N1

(8)  APOTEX’S GIFT TO THE UNIVERSITY OF SASKATCHEWAN. APOTEX, THE COMPANY IN THE OLIVIERI/UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO CASE.

(9)  THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE THAT STARTED THE PANIC. AND QUESTION: ARE YOUNG PEOPLE SUSCEPTIBLE, OR DOES THE WORST DIET AND LIFE-STYLE (NOT AGE) MAKE IT APPEAR THAT “YOUNG PEOPLE” ARE SUSCEPTIBLE?

(10)  OCT 7TH EMAIL ON H1N1

(11)  RESPONSES FROM YOU TO OCT 7TH EMAIL

A.  FROM ASHLEIGH, CITATIONS TO DISPROVE THE LINK BETWEEN AUTISM AND THIMERASOL

B.  FROM PAUL, UNDERSTANDING THE RISK

C.  FROM DOUG, MANIPULATED RESEARCH

D.  FROM RUTH’S DAUGHTER, THIMERASOL DOESN’T CAUSE AUTISM (WITH CITATIONS)

E.  FROM SHIV, FOREIGN PROTEIN CONSTITUENTS IN VACCINES LEAD TO THE VARIOUS DISEASES, MORE SO THAN THE MERCURY, ALUMINUM

(12) WHAT TO DO RE SWINE FLU

A. A FOOD SYSTEM THAT KILLS, THE ROLE OF “FACTORY FARMS” IN THE EVOLUTION OF SWINE AND BIRD (AVIAN) FLU.  REMEMBER ALL THOSE CHICKENS IN B.C. THAT WERE KILLED?

B. SIMPLE STEPS

C. FROM DENIS HALL, BE PRO-ACTIVE

(13)  AT THE UNIVERSITY: IT’S NOT INNOVATION, IT’S HYPED STATUS QUO.

(14)  “INTRODUCTION” AT THE END.  SUMMARY.

= = = = = = = = = ==  = ==  =

(1) GARY NULL ADDRESSES NEW YORK STATE HEARING, H1N1 VACCINATION (YouTube)

Thanks to Brian:    Gary Null’s testimony before the NYS Assembly Hearing (10-13-2009).

“no holds barred”    This will make you mad.

Part 1.    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y3XlJB7J5-o&NR=1

Part 2.    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ch5OuzB9L48

Part 3.    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAgWO2yq1k8&NR=1

= = = = = = = = =  == = =  = =

(2) IS GARY NULL A “QUACK”?  WHICH DOCTORS ARE TRAINED AND OBEDIENT TO “MEDI”CARE?  WHICH ONES TAKE MONEY, TRIPS AND LARGESSE FOR SPEAKING ENGAGEMENTS, FROM THE PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY?

The media contain allegations of “quacks”, bogus science, bogeymen, and conspiracy theories in response to questions surrounding the swine flu vaccinations.

I did a quick google on Null. Is he a quack? … His work is controversial.  You’ll have to make up your own mind.

I THINK that I am open-minded, but I know I pay attention to that which reinforces my thinking. Mind you, there is enough evidence in the form of court convictions to know how corrupt the pharmaceutical and chemical corporations are. Erin Brockavitch knows. Same story as the tobacco industry, but worse.

Elizabeth May, federal leader of the Green Party, went to see healthcare officials in B.C. in order to make an informed decision about H1N1. I questioned the outcome:

– Do you view Robert F Kennedy Jr as a credible source of information?  If so, you might want to read his work on swine flu.   It’s in the Oct 7th email.

Robert Kennedy’s report says there is a connection between vaccinations that contain thimerasol and autism.   2009-07-25

BUT! see the input below (item #9) from persons in our network.  It’s possible that it is not the thimerasol but other ingredients or a combination of ingredients in the vaccines, and/or cumulative impacts of numerous vaccinations.

Dr. Shiv Chopra offers:  “Bear in mind that more than mercury, aluminium, and other toxic materials, it is the foreign protein constituents in vaccines that lead to various auto-immune diseases, such as autism and other afflictions.”

I no longer trust research citations. That is a very serious situation for our society.  Corporations are buying the universities and the scientists (not ALL of them) to the point where it’s almost impossible to have confidence in “science”.  “Credentials” offer no guarantee of reliability or trustworthiness.

He who pays the piper calls the tune.  The piper is the pharmaceutical corporations in this example and they are as corrupt as hell – a statement made on very good, numerous, public and documented evidence.

It is no different from the situation today where the oil and gas corporations are paying for “science” and propaganda related to climate change, for no reason other than to ensure profits.

In the health field, in order to trust a research citation you have to go back and see whether the researchers have been funded by the pharmaceutical corporations.  And whether their methodology is sound.  Have they done things as in the Olivieri case where Apotex (drug manufacturer) tried to eliminate the tests that are more likely to reveal problems?  Are there longterm studies? – –  some of the effects are only known in the long term.  Do they have bona fide “control groups”, as is required in sound research (see Doug’s input in #9)?  Are they identifying root causes, or do they identify an association that comes about because the population shares a characteristic that is the underlying cause?  (like weakened immune systems from health-depleting diets.) Is it a case of flat-earthers whose world-view is obsolete but to which they cling, because their power, influence and life’s work is based on the flat-earth belief? They must deny that the earth is round? (Many, many drugs are extremely problematic bandaid solutions; there is another and better world-view.)  Is it a case of, as with the research trials that licensed Roundup, the ingredient (in this example glyphosate) that is identified as the herbicide, is tested in isolation without the other ingredients that make up the marketed product?  (the parallel example with the vaccines would be if you run the tests using the vaccine BEFORE the thimerasol or aluminum or foreign protein constituents, or other ingredients have been added)?

The money of the corporations has so debased research that it is impossible.  Who could possibly go through a list of citations and obtain the information you’d need to verify the science?  So we look for “peer-reviewed”.  It’s better, but not a guarantee.

– Did you ask the health officials about the CONTEXT:  probability of death in comparison to death rates that occur with flu outbreaks naturally and routinely, every year?

I have read that about 4,000 people die every year from the flu, during the flu season.  But don’t rely on my memory!

From the Globe & Mail article by Schafer (item #3 in this email): “The southern hemisphere has just gone through its flu season. In New Zealand, where 18,000 swine flu deaths had been predicted, the actual toll came to 17. Similar data have been reported from Australia and Argentina.”

– Did you see Wendy Mesley’s interview on CBC News, as a consequence of public reaction that news media are hyping H1N1?  She interviewed two doctors, one of whom was a former Chief Public Health Officer for Ontario (if I caught it right).

He addressed the question of the incidence very effectively.   The incidence of death is very small, insignificant in relation to deaths by other causes.  The problem was a 13-year old and his tearful (naturally) Father,  with whom I have heartfelt sympathy, but it is not representative (the news article is in item #7).

This doctor who was interviewed by Mesley is consistent in his statements with Schafer’s information (17 deaths in New Zealand). And it is consistent with Oct 7th email, item (4) PERSPECTIVE ON SWINE FLU, LIKELIHOOD OF DEATH.

– Anna Maria Tremonti (CBC Radio The Current) did an interview, I happened to catch the end of it.  What I heard focused on how our immune systems work, the effects of fear, for example.

(ASIDE:  Not related to the effects of fear on the immune system, we should all try to understand how fear works in us.  The cat pounces on the young bird who ignores fear in favour of the tasty seeds that lie on the ground.

The ones who survived and passed along their genes – whether birds or humans – were the ones whose wariness saved them from being eaten   . . fear is built into our evolved genes.  It’s good; but we should recognize how great a hold it has on us and, except in emergency situations, take time to gather information and think things through. Responding to the death of the 13-year old needs to be done with thought, not when fear is in the driver’s seat.  It is to the advantage of pharmaceutical profits if we stampede.)

– There is Gary Null’s address to the New York State hearing (the vaccination is mandatory for NY healthcare workers).  Unfortunately, Gary Null has some views that are challengeable and so he may lose credibility.

On the other hand, what he said to the New York State Government panel is consistent with the documentation by Robert F Kennedy Jr.   There is complexity, of course, but the information is aligned with the mercury video done by a researcher at the U of Calgary, who I called to confirm legitimacy (Oct 7 email, item #2).

The U of Calgary researcher and his colleagues put out a video that shows what happens to neural pathways in the brain when mercury is introduced. The evidence seems pretty solid to me that the vaccine manufacturers are using ethyl mercury (thimerasol) AND/OR other additives (“adjuvants”)(e.g. foreign protein constituents) for preservative and other effects.  Not surprisingly, there are now news reports about how mercury, in some forms, DOES NOT do harm.

It is a stated tactic of the chemical biotech industry (often owned by the pharmaceutical corporations) to deliberately create confusion….  “Yes, BUT, there is conflicting information.”  Intentionally.

The industry is great at using “science” to create confusion so we don’t know what is and isn’t true.  You can buy science to deal with science you don’t like.  Some of it is bona fide – but which?

Kennedy discloses the shenanigans that went on to cover up the relationship between the mercury in the vaccines (or is it other adjuvants?), increasing numbers of vaccinations given to children, and the increase in autism in particular.  It’s the tobacco industry story, the chemical industry story, the oil and gas corporate story and the pharmaceutical corporations’ multiple and unconscionable transgressions all over again.

I think that if we address “the larger issue” of the pharmaceutical corporations and their role in the Universities and in Government we would not be debating the autism connection.

Gary Null is new to me.  Had I only listened to the youtube videos of his presentation to NY State panel, I would freely distribute them because they are consistent with what I have learned about the pharmaceutical corporations over the years.  Reinforced by Kennedy, by Marcia Angell, the former editor of the New England Journal of Medicine who wrote a book on the lies of the pharma industry, etc. etc. Gary Null addresses the surrounding issues to the H1N1 vaccination, the CONTEXT in which it is set. I would recommend you listen to Null’s presentation.

= = = = = = = = = = = = == = = = =

(3) ARTHUR SCHAFER, ETHICIST, ON THE SWINE FLU

The Globe & Mail published a letter (October 26) from Arthur Schafer (Ethicist, University of Manitoba).  He addresses the incidence of H1N1 and also “effectiveness”. Note that the newspaper, not Arthur, would have assigned the word “fuss” which isn’t helpful to a public trying to sort out a very serious issue.

The swine flu fuss

Why all the media fuss about swine flu

(Fewer Canadians Interested In Getting H1N1 Shot – front page, Oct. 26)?

Somehow, a comparatively mild disease has attracted overwhelming media coverage. At the same time, a vaccine of questionable efficacy has been portrayed as our best hope for salvation.

The southern hemisphere has just gone through its flu season. In New Zealand, where 18,000 swine flu deaths had been predicted, the actual toll came to 17. Similar data have been reported from Australia and Argentina. The evidence is clear: Swine flu is a bust for doom-mongers. Perhaps this explains why so many Canadians are reluctant to be vaccinated.

Although the pandemic industry claims 90-per-cent effectiveness for the new swine flu vaccine, this does not mean the vaccine prevents flu in 90 per cent of cases. This figure refers to the percentage of people who develop antibodies in their blood after taking the vaccine. Will these people gain significant immunity as a result? There is no good scientific evidence showing this is the case.

Our public health establishment has enjoyed its day in the sun. Big Pharma has trucked fabulous profits to the bank. Perhaps it’s time for our media to turn their attention to more serious problems.

Arthur Schafer, Winnipeg

– – – – – – – – – – – – – –

From Wikipedia:

Arthur Schafer is a Canadian ethicist specializing in bioethics, philosophy of law, social philosophy and political philosophy. He is director of the Centre for Professional and Applied Ethics at the University of Manitoba.[1][2][3]

– – – – – – – –

Written by Marjaleena Repo:

There is gullibility of various sorts, including undeserved respect for the “official story” whatever it happens to be on any topic. Mocking those who sometimes perhaps clumsily question the sanctioned version does not contribute to the very necessary public discourse, but has the effect of intimidating and silencing the “differently-thinking.”

= = = = = = = = == = = = = = = ==

(4) MEDICARE DEALS IN DRUGS, NOT IN IMMUNE SYSTEMS

Aside from decorum, when I die naturally, why can’t my family throw my corpse into a bag and take it to the landfill?  (I will not be attached to my body. The job of my skin and bones will be finished.)

. . .  I stopped checking the mouse trap when I didn’t catch anything.  Then, on return from holidays I checked.  The mouse had become a mass of wiggling larvae.  The mouse was not himself.

We are not ourselves; we are our immune systems.  When our immune systems stop, we become those other things, millions of organisms, that live comfortably inside our nice warm and humid insides. When the immune system says “I’m outta here”, or “this job of keeping all you organisms in check, with little help from my owner is more than I can handle”, those organisms happily multiply.  Some of them are pretty noxious.

You cannot dispose of a corpse that dies naturally simply as you wish; the law prohibits it.  One of the reasons is that without embalming or cremation the corpse becomes a wiggling mass of not-so-nice critters.

Some of us carry H1N1 viruses for a time, under control, or a little out-of-control.  30% of the population is estimated to be carrying tuberculosis organisms.  There are colonies of fungus from spores we inhale.  People will carry the HIV (AIDS) virus all their life and never know because their immune system is in control.

Disease outbreaks can flourish in the wake of natural disasters; lots of dead people means the previously-controlled organisms are free to have a heyday. At least until they get buried or burned up in a funeral pyre.

The problem for us is that it is not in the financial interests of “medi” care to understand anything about the immune system. And yet, we each owe our life to our immune system.

Love, good food, clean water, a warm home, an unpolluted environment, healthy relationships, good schools, opportunities to experience and learn about the world and one’s self, fresh air and exercise, no war, the chance to achieve your potential (the reason for your being) . . . the fear-filled threat of disease would disappear.  We would all be happier and safer with strong immune systems.

Poverty can mean a lack of all those things that strengthen the immune system. And so the diseases and fear will spread. And it threatens us all.  Or it doesn’t . . .  When we help look after others, we look after ourselves.

What exactly is it that we want out of life?  If you had to figure it out for yourself (unaided by advertising to create your “wants”), exactly what do you want?  Do you not want it for other people, too?  Does it not come back to be good for you and your children?  You can help do things that will strengthen the immune systems of other people – – out of SELF interest if you like.

I know how I contracted tuberculosis (see the last item, the “INTRODUCTION”).  And I know that tuberculosis is on the rise. I know that it is going to threaten some of you.

I know it for a number of reasons, just one of which is that the medi-care system relies entirely now on very expensive and nausea-causing drugs to TREAT the disease.  Medi-care currently does almost nothing to screen for and to isolate those who are contagious (which is how/why I breathed in TB organisms).

As long as the pharmaceutical industry is running the show at the universities and in the “medi”care system, the public interest in screening, isolating and removal of cause is lost.  It’s a recipe for more disease outbreaks – exactly what is happening with tuberculosis in Canada today.  (I use that EXAMPLE because I am very familiar with it.  It is my story.)

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = =  ==

(5)  UPDATE ON NIGERIAN GOVERNMENT COURT CASE AGAINST PFIZER OVER DRUG TRIALS THAT KILLED PEOPLE.

It looks as though the Nigerians have largely settled “out of court” for millions of dollars and no surprise, the pharmaceutical corporations deny, deny, deny.  See the article at http://sandrafinley.ca/?p=4415 2009-04-06   $75 million.  Pfizer settles Nigerian drug case out of court  (criminal charges for death of children)

Information on the rush by the pharmaceutical corporations to patent the next cure for tuberculosis, because the organism has evolved in Eastern Europe, in Africa, etc. to be resistant to existing drug protocol, can be found in the listings at  http://sandrafinley.ca/?p=4401 (for people in Guatemala.)

It is a deadly game that is not in the public interest.  And it’s a no-brainer.  The next generation of antibiotics or tuberculosis “cure” or whatever, has to be more toxic than the last round.

Eventually “the cure” is as noxious as the disease organism.  AND it is so expensive that third world countries can’t afford it. Meanwhile the pharmaceutical corporations kill people in third world countries in their eagerness to be the first ones to patent the new “cure” and cash in on the profits.

The current approach to drugs is not “innovative”, as the University communications spin would have us believe; it is a deadly spiral.

My own case and experiment is instructive and was done with the cooperation of two doctors, the then-head of TB Control in Saskatchewan and a naturopathic doctor.

I was in a unique situation to experiment under their guidance: the disease was active in my body (I was very sick), but the TB had not advanced to the state of being contagious.

I did not take the drug treatment because, as I appealed to the head of TB Control:  we have to figure out a way to address these diseases without drugs.  We know absolutely that the organisms evolve to be resistant to the drugs and we know that any new drug has to be more toxic and expensive, therefore unaffordable by all except the rich.

In less time than the 9-month drug treatment, I overcame the TB organism without drugs, by addressing immune system issues.  (NOTE:  my case was unique.  I am not recommending anyone do what I did – – I am saying that it was a valid experiment with positive outcome.)

The new head of TB Control does not want to hear my experience.  There is absolutely no curiosity, no interest in true “innovation” or experimentation if it doesn’t fit the drug mould — even if it is obvious that the drug mould is taking us down a suicidal path.

I googled for an update on the charges brought by the Government of Nigeria against Big Pharma (Pfizer) for the deaths it caused by using human beings as guinea pigs in their attempt to develop the “next generation” of drugs.   We have been following this story that  gave rise to John le Carré’s novel-made-into-a-movie, “The Constant Gardener”.

= = = = = = = = == = = = = = = ==

(6)  THE CONSTANT GARDENER.  VIDO (VACCINE INFECTIOUS DISEASES ORGANIZATION) AT THE UNIVERSITY OF SASKATCHEWAN.

I advise people to read the real life comments in “The Constant Gardener“. Le Carré says the story in his book is a holiday card version of what the pharmaceutical corporations do in the real world. His books are well researched.

(Another internationally-famous author, Henning Mankell, lives back-and-forth between Sweden and Africa, and has written a book similar to “The Constant Gardener“.  Thanks to Howard for drawing “Kennedy’s Brain” to attention.  I haven’t read it.    http://www.thenewpress.com/index.php?option=com_title&task=view_title&metaproductid=1673 )

I am very curious about what John le Carré  knew, or intuited.  In “The Constant Gardener” part of the search to uncover the truth about the pharmaceutical-company-related deaths in Africa takes place in Canada, at the University of Saskatchewan.  It was pretty shocking to me to be reading about the U of S in “The Constant Gardener”!

(Wikipedia):  The Constant Gardener is a 2001 novel by John le Carré. It tells the story of Justin Quayle, a British diplomat whose activist wife is murdered. Believing that there is more behind the murder, he seeks to uncover the truth behind her death, and finds an international conspiracy of corrupt bureaucracy and pharmaceutical money.

John le Carré writes in the book’s afterword, “By comparison with the reality, my story [is] as tame as a holiday postcard.” [1])”

From a blog:  “An important part of Quayle’s quest takes him to Saskatchewan, where he finds one of the drug’s main developers.”

At the time of seeing the movie I was weak and in the early stages of overcoming the TB organisms in my body.  I thought I was going to see a gardening movie of some kind!

I walked out of the theatre thinking I had been on some outer space hallucinatory experience.  The movie was about tuberculosis in a spy-thriller John le Carré setting. It was a disease I had thought had been eradicated from Canada and most of elsewhere – – which I now had.  Part of the action was at the University of Saskatchewan where I had just been for medical attention.  The timing of seeing the movie was all too bizarre and disorienting.

I have always wondered why le Carré  placed part of the action in Saskatchewan?  The only thing I could think was that the U of S is a big centre for biotechnology (developing crops that are resistant to chemical applications) and I knew there are biotech pharmaceuticals at the U of S. That was the only link I could think of.  I thought that John le Carré might have known more?

Later, when I read that the Bill and Linda Gates Foundation was donating a lot of money to help find the cure for the renewed rising threat of tuberculosis in the world, I wanted to tell the Gates:  put your money into finding alternatives.

If my one experiment was successful in combating the disease without potent drugs, then it is POSSIBLE that it can be done.  But as long as the pharmaceutical corporations are involved, the ONLY avenue that will be explored is the drug option.  And it is a wrong-headed approach, obviously.  You might think you are God, but you cannot stop evolution (drug-resistant organisms).

I thought that John le Carré  (his pen name) would have a better chance of talking to and persuading the Gates than me (ha!). Also, I wanted to thank David Cornwell (his real name) for his book. So I found an email address for the publisher.

I requested that the publisher forward my email.  After explanations and thanks, the email requested that Cornwell contact the Gates Foundation:

Bill Gates should read “The Constant Gardener” to understand the lay of the land with the pharmaceutical corporations, their murderous ways, and he might re-consider where he wants to donate his money.

Why not ask?!  It gets it out of my system, and it is supportive of people like Cornwell.  He’s not only a good guy, he is putting his neck on the line.  He needs our support.

I received a reply!

Mon 21/05/2007 5:03 AM

Dear Miss Finley

Your message has found its way to me, John le Carre’s agent.  I shall make sure that he sees it.

Yours sincerely

Bruce Hunter

David Higham Associates

Visit our website at www.davidhigham.co.uk

Monsieur le Carré hasn’t let me know if he communicated on the matter with Mr. Gates!  Oh well, my modus operandi is to “put it out there”.  And then let it go.  I don’t need to know what happened; that’s beyond my control.

That was all I knew, until this last week (Nov 2009). Howard Woodhouse’s book “Selling Out”, in the chapter on the synchrotron at the University of Saskatchewan talks about VIDO.

VIDO = Vaccine Infectious Diseases Organization at the University of Saskatchewan.   http://www.vido.org/

Excerpts:

VIDO is a not-for-profit organization owned by the University of Saskatchewan. A separate Board of Advisors contributes industry expertise and practical guidance. … VIDO continues to be competitive nationally and internationally, with more than 80 awarded U.S. patents.  . . . . .  VIDO is one of four Canadian teams offered funding through the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation’s Grand Challenges in Global Health initiative.

(If you didn’t know that the University of Saskatchewan is a wholly-owned subsidiary of various corporations, or about to become so, you SHOULD know!)

MAYBE John le Carré knew about VIDO, the work being done at the University of Saskatchewan for the pharmaceutical corporations, when he wrote “The Constant Gardener”?  Ramble through the VIDO website – it’s all there.

What University of Saskatchewan professor, Howard Woodhouse, makes clear in his book “Selling Out” and which is there again in the VIDO information is that WE citizens are paying the COSTS for the corporations.

The details and the extent, the amounts of the subsidies, are well documented in “Selling Out”.

It is “socialization of the costs and privatization of the profits” — for what is beneficial to the corporations, not what is necessarily beneficial for citizens.

The cost to students is financially large. There are “cutbacks” and higher tuition fees because the money is sucked up by the research for the pharmaceutical and other corporations. The University Administration hypes it as “Innovation”.

Conflicts-of-interest abound: professors in veterinary medicine who promote factory-size pig barns (origins of swine flu) receive money from that industry. That industry is now going into bankruptcy.  It was heavily subsidized by tax-payers, resisted by many communities.  It forced smaller, more humane and health-giving local meat producers out of production.  It also forced small producers in other countries out-of-business and into dependency upon imported cheap, inferior food from Canada. . . . Our Government and our University working for us in “public-private-partnerships”.

The “innovative” corporate model adopted by the University does not reflect our values. The conflicts-of-interest created by the “partnerships” should not be tolerated.

Old-timers in our network know the story where I challenged a salaried full-time government scientist who works at “Innovation Place” at the University.  Simultaneously he makes “up to ten thousand dollars” per contract he does for the very corporations he is supposed to be regulating. And which he had been doing for 8 years at the time. I received a letter from a lawyer threatening to sue me if I should say such-and-such to Saskatoon City Council about the situation.  (The City had a pesticide bylaw under consideration. There was a serious conflict-of-interest involved.)

The work at the University is NOT “innovative”, as they keep heralding and would have us believe.  The drug approach is the status quo.  The pharmaceutical corporations are corrupt.  And we are the silly ones putting up the money, in more ways than we know.  If more people knew, there would be a revolt. .. I think it’s well under way.

== = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =

(7) “SELLING OUT”, THE OLIVIERI STORY AND THE SYNCHROTRON RELATED TO H1N1

If Gary Null’s presentation (item #1) makes you mad, Howard Woodhouse’s case studies in his book “Selling Out, Academic Freedom and the Corporate Market” will add to your anger.

More on that in item “APOTEX’S GIFT TO THE UNIVERSITY OF SASKATCHEWAN.  APOTEX, THE COMPANY IN THE OLIVIERI/UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO CASE”.

It is more important to understand the significance of what is happening – which I find alarming.  H1N1 is just another part of the whole.  It’s a larger issue than swine flu.

Universities are critical to the maintenance of the knowledge base of the society.  Effective problem-solving is contingent upon a solid base of information, of “truth” and understanding.

We need “the truth”, an uncontaminated knowledge base if we are to keep learning.  The life of the individual and of the community is about grappling with and learning from problems in succession, one after the other.

If you fail to solve the problems, and to change through what you have learned, if you fail to move forward, you will live in misery.  Guaranteed.  It is true of the individual; it is true of the community.

The CITIZENS of this country understood the value of “the search for truth”, of learning.  They built universities to advance and to share knowledge.

Private ownership of knowledge is a recipe for keeping the population ignorant and poor.  Think of times past when the knowledge base was owned by powerful churches.  Rich clergy and poor peasants.

A theme of mine has been that an economy is based on a resource.  If you can own the resource you profit handsomely.  The Winnipeg “Wheat Kings” attempting to control the trade in wheat which led farmers to band together to defy poverty: outcome, the Canadian Wheat Board. The economy of the Maritimes built on fish. The economy based on oil and gas.

And now we have the “knowledge” or “information” economy.  Like the farmers who recognized “the issue”, we are now engaged in a fight with corporations over control of the universities and the whole system of “education”, our information and knowledge base.

Woodhouse’s book shows how far the pendulum has swung back toward private ownership of the knowledge base. We are the ones footing the bill.

The universities hype the status quo and call it “innovation”.  In the case of medi-care the status quo is increasing numbers of people who come down with disease and developmental problems.

TRUE innovation would, by definition, lead to a reversal in the numbers of people who come down with disease and developmental problems.

Corporations have no interest in removing the many known causes of disease.  Their interest is the status quo. The status quo is guaranteed as long as we accept corporate partnerships with the universities and government.  That is obvious.

More drugs, more vaccinations, more chemicals, more factory food, more factory-produced, genetically-designed crops, swine, bird, cattle, cows and fish, more patents for corporate ownership of life forms, are ALL the status quo.  Corruption of science and of the regulatory system is the status quo – – that has been well documented over the 10 years of the operation of our network.

There is nothing innovative or delightful about the status quo.  It ensures a continuation of the trend line:  increasing numbers of people who come down with disease and developmental problems.

If the university and the medicare system and the Departments of Health were measured by “results” in the levels of healthfulness in the community (the trendlines), they fail.

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = ==

(8)  APOTEX’S GIFT TO THE UNIVERSITY OF SASKATCHEWAN. APOTEX, THE COMPANY IN THE OLIVIERI/UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO CASE.

The Olivieri case is internationally known.  The company that tried to silence Oivieri by repeated threats to sue her is Apotex.

In spite of that record, the University of Saskatchewan has embraced Apotex as a partner.  If the law worked for corporations as it does for individuals, the U of S would not be able to take money from Apotex because Apotex would be in jail.  One has to ask, what VALUES does the University embrace and role-model for students?

Dr. Nancy Olivieri was doing test trials for a drug manufactured by Apotex.  The results showed a loss of sustained efficacy.  And suggested increased liver fibrosis in her patients (children).  She believed that her patients should be told and did so.

(P. 95, “Selling Out”)  “As soon as Dr. Olivieri took action to inform both her patients and the authorities, Apotex terminated both trials in May 1996 and threatened her with legal action.”

(The use of the “justice system” to intimidate people is a VERY common tactic of the pharmaceutical-chemical-biotech corporations, the same tactic used on Percy Schmeiser (gmo canola), on a small dairy in Vermont that advertised its milk as the product of cows that are not injected with bovine growth hormone, the same as tried on me by the scientist from the Pest Management Regulatory Agency of Health Canada (responsible for the regulation of chemicals, and so on.)

P. 95 “At the same time Apotex began efforts to persuade medical administrators and patients in Toronto, as well as regulatory agencies and the scientific community that L1 was effective and safe and should be in wider use.  Apotex proposed a new treatment for .. patients in which annual liver biopsy, the test that had led to the identification of both of the unexpected risks of L1, would not be an integral part of the safety monitoring …”.

The University of Toronto did not stand behind Dr. Olivieri until they were embarrassed into doing so. “A wide coalition of individuals and groups coalesced” in support of Dr. Olivieri, including respected experts from Harvard and Oxford Universities.  There was media exposure.

Why did the U of Toronto not support its faculty?    “Selling Out“, P. 129:  “Corporate Connections and University Autonomy

Apotex’s $7 million investment of U of T’s Faculty of Pharmacy was considerable; however, if the biomedical centre that had initially been proposed in the early 1990s had materialized, the company’s stake in the medical sciences at the university would have been far greater.  The centre was shelved when the controversy between the company and Dr Olivieri over L1 became public …”

So now, look what’s happening at the University of Saskatchewan.

The University of Saskatchewan welcomes Apotex in spite of its well-known history.  The following is one announcement of the money going from Apotex to the U of S.  It’s not the full story.  You can google to find more examples.

http://announcements.usask.ca/news/archive/2008/09/university_of_s_62.html

September 23, 2008

University of Saskatchewan Pharmacy Education and Research Receives Boost

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE – September 23, 2008

2008-09-13-PH&N

Students and faculty in the University of Saskatchewan’s College of Pharmacy gathered today in their pharmacy practice lab to thank Apotex Inc., Canada’s largest pharmaceutical company, for their recent gift to the college.

The $1.5 million donation from Apotex Inc., the largest single gift ever received by the college, will support three areas:

– a state-of-the-art pharmacy practice laboratory, which simulates a real-life pharmacy for undergraduate students, in the new Academic Health Science Centre

– additional research funding for faculty and graduate researchers

– increased graduate student support, providing crucial funding for continued study

“Our faculty members have achieved national and international distinction for their research activities in a variety of areas and we will build on that success by supporting new and innovative research ideas and projects,” said U of S Dean of Pharmacy and Nutrition Dennis Gorecki. “We have established a premiere graduate award to support outstanding students. And we can look to the future, with the completion of the Academic Health Science Centre and the Apotex Pharmacy Professional Practice Centre, to further enhance our undergraduate pharmacy program.”

“Apotex is a great Canadian business success story,” says Jack Kay, President of Apotex Inc. “but it does not stop there – giving back to our communities is just as important. This gift will help reduce the shortage of pharmacists in this country, and support great research and graduate work at the University of Saskatchewan. We are leaders in the support of pharmacy and we have committed over $16 million to all the Faculties of Pharmacy across Canada.”

The newly named Apotex Pharmacy Professional Practice Centre, currently located in the Thorvaldson Building on campus, will relocate to the university’s Academic Health Sciences Centre when it is complete. The Academic Health Sciences Centre will offer leading facilities to enable U of S health experts to teach, conduct research and practise in the community. In addition, the project will expand learning resources for students, healthcare instructors, clinical supervisors and practitioners across the province.

Located in the heart of Saskatoon, the University of Saskatchewan is one of the leading medical doctoral universities in Canada. With 58 degrees, diplomas and certificates in over 100 areas of study, the University is uniquely positioned in the areas of human, animal and plant studies. World-class research facilities, renowned faculty and award winning students make the U of S a leader in post-secondary education.

-30-

For more information, contact:

Lisa Green, Development Officer

College of Pharmacy & Nutrition

University of Saskatchewan

Telephone: (306) 966-5823

Email: lisa.green   AT   usask.ca

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = =  ==

(9)  THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE THAT STARTED THE PANIC. AND QUESTION: ARE YOUNG PEOPLE SUSCEPTIBLE, OR DOES THE WORST DIET AND LIFE-STYLE (NOT AGE) MAKE IT APPEAR THAT “YOUNG PEOPLE” ARE SUSCEPTIBLE?

Note that the question of CONTEXT in the news coverage of this teen’s unfortunate death is largely (not completely) underplayed. It states “swine flu has now killed close to 100 people across Canada” without saying how many people die every year from “the flu”.

The article waits until the tenth paragraph to provide context: “Most victims – about 90 per cent – had underlying health conditions. “Death is a rare event, and it’s a particularly rare event in young people,” said Dr. Arlene King, …”

The teen who died was “healthy”. … I, seemingly healthy and active, suddenly came down with an active case of tuberculosis (diagnosed before it was contagious) 4 or 5 years ago.  Why did I suddenly get TB?

I recuperated, NOT by taking the drugs for TB, but in part by addressing an underlying cause that goes undetected by normal allopathic (western) medicine.

A naturopathic doctor tested and concluded that my immune system was most likely overloaded by mycotoxins, the product of overgrown fungal colonizations in my body, of which I was completely unaware.

Old-timers in our network may remember mycotoxins from the work on GMO crops.  GMO crops have a higher incidence of the fungus fusarium.  Grain with fusarium is not allowed into the feed chain for humans or for animals because of the deadly mycotoxins they produce.

The remedy for my particular case of TB was to combat the fungal colonizations, take an anti-fungal agent and change my diet:  eat absolutely nothing that will feed fungal growth (sugar); avoid foods that are known to sometimes carry spores; if eating nuts, heat them up first to kill spores. No alcohol because it, like sugar, feeds fungal growth. I used a book of diets to combat candida yeast infections.  Same thing.  I got lots of rest and religiously took sun (vitamin D) every day.  As close to full body exposure as possible.  At first I was so weak I could only walk a block.  But every day I went a little further. It took 6 months to return to full health, which was less than the prescribed time for the drug treatment, 9 months.  The drugs are expensive and have side effects, not the least of which is nausea to the point where people want to stop taking the drugs, and do.  Which aids the development of resistant strains.

NOTE:  I do not advocate that everyone with TB should not take the drugs.  I was in a unique situation:  early detection meant I wasn’t contagious and I had the luxery of time to experiment.  There needs to be more experimentation to determine a “best path” forward.

When the news report says “no underlying health conditions I wonder whether the medical profession knows this for certain?  Allopathic (western) practitioners would have said “no underlying health conditions” in my case.

Also, when it is stated that young people are “at risk” for H1N1 I wonder.  Young adults in our society should be in their prime, the least susceptible to disease.  Is AGE the criterion?  If they happen to be the largest demographic with the worst diet and lifestyle (too much sugar, fast food, processed food, and booze coupled with not enough sleep and too much sedentary time, not enough fresh air and exercise) then it is diet and lifestyle that make them susceptible to H1N1.  Age is coincidental.

– – – – – – – –

THE NEWSPAPER REPORT  (thanks to Levi)

Sandy I saw your internet research on shots and I just wanted you to read this.

Levi

TORONTO – The swine-flu death of an otherwise healthy hockey-playing teen came without warning and should serve as a lesson to parents to keep a close eye on their ill children, the boy’s grief-stricken father said Tuesday.

Paul Frustaglio said it took barely more than a day for the H1N1 flu virus to kill Evan – his “best friend” – who turned 13 last month, a fatality that public health officials called rare.

“He fell so quickly,” Frustaglio told The Canadian Press. “I was watching him. I was there when he died.”

Evan’s death Monday came on the same day health authorities across Canada began rolling out a vaccination program against H1N1.

The teen would not have been considered a priority for the flu shot because he wasn’t in a high-risk group.

The Grade 8 student began feeling ill over the weekend during a hockey tournament. His symptoms included fever and some vomiting.

His dad took him to a walk-in clinic on Sunday afternoon, where he was seen and sent home with advice to take over-the-counter medication.

The family felt confident it was a simple case of flu that would soon pass. That seemed to be happening. By Monday morning, his fever had broken and he was no longer nauseated. The family thought he was on the mend.

Evan asked to take a bath. Ten minutes later, as his horrified father watched, he suddenly went limp. His father tried CPR as paramedics rushed to the west-end home. “They worked on my son feverishly for over two hours,” Frustaglio said. “His heart wasn’t responding. The disease had taken over his heart.”

The tragedy follows the death Saturday of a 10-year-old eastern Ontario girl from H1N1. Vanetia Warner of Cornwall, Ont., was sick for several days before her condition rapidly deteriorated. She died Saturday in Ottawa. It was not immediately known if she had any underlying medical conditions.

The swine flu has now killed close to 100 people across Canada. Ontario has had close to 30 deaths, six of them children, since April.

Three more deaths in British Columbia over the past week raised that province’s total to 12.

Most victims – about 90 per cent – had underlying health conditions.

“Death is a rare event, and it’s a particularly rare event in young people,” said Dr. Arlene King, Ontario’s medical officer of health.

Why the same strain of virus can cause mild symptoms in one healthy person and be lethal in another is a mystery, although its newness may be a factor.

“We don’t have all of the answers,” King said. “The key thing for all of us is to try to prevent ourselves from getting infected to begin with.”

Dr. David McKeown, Toronto’s medical officer of health, said Evan had “mild asthma,” something his father disputed. “Evan didn’t have asthma; he had been prescribed puffers a few years ago when he had a cold,” Frustaglio said.  A spokeswoman for Toronto public health later said the boy did not have asthma and the earlier statement had resulted from some confusion concerning his medical records.

Mary Margaret Crapper said Evan had no underlying health issues that public health was aware of.

Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty expressed sympathy for the family, calling it a “terrible tragedy.” The province, he said, was doing everything it could to provide a vaccination program as quickly as possible. “I continue to have confidence in our public health officials,” McGuinty said. “They’re making the right decisions, getting the vaccine into the communities as quickly as they can and respecting the order of priorities that they’ve put in place.”

Frustaglio refused to criticize the walk-in clinic, saying he was in too much grief to think about what might have been done differently.

However, he did warn parents against complacency or thinking that patients with swine flu will show symptoms for many days before deteriorating gradually.

“This didn’t even take a day and a half – it hit my son within 10 minutes,” he said. “If any one of your children has any kind of flu-like symptoms, please don’t take your eyes off of them. Make sure you get the medical attention you need and, if at any time, they don’t seem right, especially with their breathing, just get medical attention.”

Evan’s family began taking Tamiflu after his death as a precaution and immediately informed Evan’s teammates of what had happened so they, too, could seek medical attention.

Evan is survived by his brother Will, 10, and his mom, Anne-Marie, who was too distressed to speak about her loss. “I’m really having a hard time with this,” she said.

Ontario Health Minister Deb Matthews said the “very sad case” should impress on people the need to get inoculated. “It doesn’t protect just you, it protects all the people around you,” Matthews said.

Evans’ death sparked an outpouring of sympathy and tributes on Facebook and YouTube, with numerous pictures and even a tribute video.

One Facebook writer said she hoped the tragedy would heighten awareness of the dangers of H1N1. “I feel for your loss; my heart aches for your sorrow,” Tracey Parr wrote. “Hope Evan’s passing will heighten the awareness of this flu, and preventative measures needed to be taken.”

Frustaglio called Evan a “wonderful” boy who was “full of spirit.” His son had switched this year to the Hill Academy north of Toronto – a small school with an emphasis on athletics – because “it was all about hockey.”

“My son is gone. He was here just 24 hours ago and now he’s not here. He was 13. He didn’t deserve to die,” he said. “Whenever you hear stories like this in the press, I say to myself, ‘Oh my god, I can never imagine how I could ever live without one of my kids,’ and now I’m asking myself that question.”

= = = = = = = = =  = = = = = = = =

(10)  OCT 7TH EMAIL ON H1N1

For the first email on H1N1, click on:   2009-10-07 I want parents to know this about vaccinations, mercury, Rumsfeld, and money devoid of conscience   (Rumsfeld’s connection to Tamiflu)

The CONTENTS are as follows:

(1)  FOX NEWS OCT 6TH, WHY YOU SHOULD NOT VACCINATE YOUR CHILDREN AGAINST THE FLU

(2)  UNIVERSITY OF CALGARY, DEPT OF MEDICINE,  HOW MERCURY CAUSES BRAIN NEURON DEGENERATION

(3)  ROBERT F KENNEDY JR ON LINK BETWEEN VACCINATIONS (THIMERASOL, MERCURY) AND AUTISM.

(4)  PERSPECTIVE ON SWINE FLU, LIKELIHOOD OF DEATH

(5)  DONALD RUMSFIELD’S (BUSH ADMINISTRATION) FINANCIAL LINK TO THE FLU VACCINE

It’s devilish trying to find “the truth”!

An adjuvant is “a pharmacological agent added to a drug to increase or aid its effect.”  It includes preservatives.  Ethyl mercury (trade name thimerasol) is used as a preservative in some vaccines, as are other agents foreign to our body.

If you must get the swine flu vaccination, especially if it is being given to children, I would recommend that you at least ask for a list of the adjuvants in the vaccine.  Know what each of the adjuvants does.

Mercury is a heavy metal.  Heavy metals cause serious deterioration in neural pathways in the brain.  The banning of lead in gasoline and in paint are examples of efforts to prevent brain damage in humans by lowering exposure to heavy metals.  As I understand, mercury is more poisonous to the brain than lead and other heavy metals.

Increasing numbers of vaccinations mean increasing levels of heavy metals in the body, IF ethyl mercury is an adjuvant in the vaccinations.  Mercury is not the only problematic adjuvant, just the best-known.  Robert F Kennedy Jr makes the case for the connection between mercury in vaccinations and increases in autism.  (See #9 below for alternative interpretations.)

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = =  ==

(11) RESPONSES FROM YOU TO OCT 7TH EMAIL

A.  FROM ASHLEIGH, CITATIONS TO DISPROVE THE LINK BETWEEN AUTISM AND THIMERASOL

B.  FROM PAUL, UNDERSTANDING THE RISK

C.  FROM DOUG, MANIPULATED RESEARCH

D.  FROM RUTH’S DAUGHTER, THIMERASOL DOESN’T CAUSE AUTISM (WITH CITATIONS)

E.  FROM SHIV, FOREIGN PROTEIN CONSTITUENTS IN VACCINES LEAD TO THE VARIOUS DISEASES, MORE SO THAN THE MERCURY, ALUMINUM

A.  FROM ASHLEIGH, CITATIONS TO DISPROVE THE LINK BETWEEN AUTISM AND THIMERASOL

With thanks to Ashleigh Mattern:

Hi there,

I received your email at editor  AT   thesheaf.com, but I am writing this letter as a concerned individual, not as the editor of a newspaper.

Please, before you use your reputation and connection to a respectable political party to spread information, make sure that information is correct. Here are some additional links on the topics of vaccination.

From article “Autism prevalence” by Dr. Stephen Novella: “Autism rates continued to rise at a steady rate, essentially killing the hypothesis that thimerosal is a significant contributor to autism.” http://www.theness.com/neurologicablog/?p=1049

From article “More evidence for vaccine safety” also by Novella: “The BBC reports today of a National Health Service study that shows that autism rates are consistent at about 1% among all age groups. If true, this has profound implications for the now-discredited notion that autism rates are rising and that this rise is linked to vaccines.” http://www.theness.com/neurologicablog/?p=940

The following is from “Mercury Rising: Exposing the Vaccine-Autism Myth” on http://www.skeptic.com/eskeptic/07-06-20#feature

“A Vast Government Conspiracy?

So what do vaccine opponents make of the evidence against the vaccine-autism hypothesis? Mostly, they assert a vast conspiracy propagated by government and industry. It is proposed that government agencies such as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, in conjunction with scientists with varying ties to the pharmaceutical industry, have gone to great lengths to suppress evidence supporting a link between vaccines and autism. Indeed, this was the main point of Robert Kennedy Jr.’s Rolling Stone article. Kennedy and others claim that a conspiracy does exist and was formally discussed at a top-secret meeting in Simpsonwood, Georgia in 2000.

One hotly discussed result of this meeting is the purported doctoring of data by Thomas Verstraeten who, according to the vaccine opponents, presented data supporting the autism-vaccine link but later altered the data to support the opposite conclusion because he was, by then, employed by a large pharmaceutical company. Verstraeten has denied such manipulation and the data he reports support the conclusions reached by a number of other independent researchers.15 The problem is that the only evidence of doctored data sets, dubious activity at the Simpsonwood meeting, and assorted cover-ups seems to come from a small number of zealous vaccine opponents who can offer no corroborating evidence to support the hearsay.”

There is also some great information about the swine flu, etc., in the article “Swine Flu Vaccine Fearmongering” here: http://www.skeptic.com/eskeptic/09-09-23#feature

As you have asked me and the countless other people on your mailing list to consider some new ideas, I urge you to read and consider these links.

Thanks so much for your time,

…. Thanks Ashleigh.

– – – – – – – – – – –

B.  FROM PAUL, UNDERSTANDING THE RISK

I am an employee of an organization that, in fact, does promote flu vaccination for at risk persons and has done so for many years.  There will be risk involved in virtually everything we do.  It is important, but also difficult, for individuals to try to understand and manage risk.

It is valuable to question most practices including those done in the name of public health.  It is valuable to question the information provided by any organization.  I am involved in issues related to tobacco use and I expect am known for questioning much of what is said and done under the guise of protecting health.  Bill C-32, passed just this week, is a good example of witnessing statements that were, I suggest, inaccurate, even though the basic purpose and general outcome of the Bill may have been positive.

Flu vaccine does contain mercury, and this does mean there is a theoretical possibility of health issues resulting from it.  The goal is certainly to stop the need for additive mercury but as yet this is not the case.  Fewer vaccines now contain this additive.

We can only respond to what we understand at the moment.  The good news, to use that phrase, is that the form of mercury resulting from this intake is excreted very quickly in children in comparison to other forms of the element and methods of intake.  It is also noteworthy that some of the increased costs associated with its removal are real and not a total fabrication of industry.  This is perhaps less important to middle class America but is a concern for children in many countries.

I am not suggesting that increased pressure in Canada to remove this preservative may be disadvantageous but the question remains as to the relative risk associated with the use of the current vaccine.  We would wish that all children have very good diets, are physically active and live in a positive environment (and personally I hope that will exclude nuclear energy as a major power source, for example) but we also appreciate that not to be the case.  For some our immune systems are what they are especially for children.

I think I am not overly naïve about large industry but at the same time I am content to know that rabies protection is available when I do run with the wolves.

Thanks again for all of your information,

Paul Van Loon

paul.vanloon   AT   sk.lung.ca

Health Educator

Lung Association of Saskatchewan

—– – – – –  – — –  — – – – –

C.  FROM DOUG, MANIPULATED RESEARCH

Doug’s point is the same one as made in the Olivieri case, where the drug manufacturer “proposed a new treatment .. in which annual liver biopsy, the test that had led to the identification of both of the unexpected risks .. would not be an integral part of the safety monitoring .. “.

He writes:

Yes, very similar story, but make sure not to get fooled into thinking it is only the mercury that is the problem. The immune challenges created by non-mercury vaccines can cause some horrible issues too.

Like most people don’t know that when a safety profile is done for a vaccine, it is NOT compared to a saline placebo (other drugs are compared to placebos for safety tolerance), but is compared to another vaccine with a “known” safety profile. So in essence, there is NEVER a control group receiving placebo.

Sheri Tenpenny , MD is a MD who uses actual CDC (Center for Disease Control) documents and med journal studies to go over a lot of the myths about vaccine “effectiveness” let alone even “safety”. It’s a great DVD for the science that is involved. AND she used to be head ER doctor at a huge Ohio hospital and health region.

http://www.realityzone.com/vaccinescdc.html

– – – – – – – – – – – – – –

D.  FROM RUTH’S DAUGHTER, THIMERASOL DOESN’T CAUSE AUTISM (WITH CITATIONS)

Hello Sandra:

I forwarded your information to my daughter, who is National Health Reporter for CBC Radio.  This is her reply; thought you would like to have it.

Best regards,

Ruth

Hi Mom,

I never underestimate the influence of the big dollars of pharma in covering up harms. But the thimerosal/autism link has been definitively de-bunked for some years. You’ll see the statement from the Canadian Pediatric Society below, and I’ve bolded the most easily understood, convincing part of this. But still the “theory” about thimerosal and autism continues, and as a result there have been huge outbreaks of sometimes deadly diseases (including measles) in Europe and North America, because parents have  been frightened off from getting their children vaccinated.  So this should be shared and distributed to people who are still circulating the outdated and erroneous information. Not saying thimerosal isn’t bad, just that it doesn’t cause autism!

Love,

(Your daughter)

THIMEROSAL-CONTAINING VACCINES

Thimerosal, a compound that contains ethyl mercury, has been used as an additive to biological therapies and vaccines because of its effect in preventing bacterial contamination, particularly in opened, multidose vials. In 1997, the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Modernization Act called for a review and assessment of the risk of all mercury-containing foods and drugs. This action stimulated the United States Public Health Service and the American Academy of Pediatrics to issue a joint statement in 1999 (18) calling for the removal of thimerosal from vaccines. This action was undertaken as a precautionary measure; there was no evidence that ethyl mercury was harmful at the doses being administered to infants.

Of note, at that time in Canada, in contrast to the United States, the regularly used infant immunization product (pentavalent DTaPIPVHib vaccine) did not contain thimerosal. Only two infant thimerosal-containing vaccines were used – hepatitis B vaccine and influenza vaccine; the latter was not administered to infants younger than six months of age, the age/size of infant of concern. Hence, any concerns about excessive ethyl mercury exposure in young Canadian infants were without foundation. Since 1999, several studies (19-23) have been conducted to evaluate the safety of thimerosal in vaccines. These studies were reviewed in detail by the IOM (10) in 2001 and 2004 with a focus on autism. The IOM Committee concluded that the evidence favoured rejection of a causal relationship between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism, as well as MMR vaccine and autism (10). In the absence of experimental or human evidence that vaccination affects metabolic, developmental, immune, or other physiological or molecular mechanisms that are related causally to development of autism, the IOM concluded that the hypotheses generated to date are theoretical. In a separate critical review (24) of published original data, a link between thimerosal-containing vaccines and ASD was not shown. Epidemiological studies that supported a link demonstrated significant design flaws that invalidated conclusions of these studies (10,24). Additional data from Canada published since 2004 also showed no association between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism (25).

An important factor to consider is what has happened to autism rates since the removal of thimerosal from vaccines. In studies from Canada (25), Denmark (20) and the United States (26) the rates of autism have continued to increase despite removal of thimerosal from vaccines.

Thus, the evidence is in, and the assessment of purported causality is clear. The MMR vaccine and immunization with thimerosal-containing vaccines are not causally associated with, nor are they a cause of, autism or ASD. There is mounting evidence (27) that ASD has a strong genetic component – a very plausible cause for the disorder.

REFERENCES

1.    Collet JP, MacDonald N, Cashman N, Pless R. Monitoring signals for vaccine safety: The assessment of individual adverse event reports by an expert advisory committee. Advisory Committee on Causality Assessment. Bull World Health Organ 2000;78:178-85.

2.    Folb PI, Bernatowska E, Chen R, et al. A global perspective on vaccine safety and public health: The Global Advisory Committee on Vaccine Safety. Am J Public Health 2004;94:1926-31.

3.    Canadian Paediatric Society, Infectious Diseases and Immunization Committee [Principal author: J Embree]. Measles-mumps-rubella vaccine and autistic spectrum disorder: A hypothesis only. Paediatr Child Health 2001;6:387-9.

4.    Wakefield AJ, Murch SH, Anthony A, et al. Ileal-lymphoidnodular hyperplasia, non-specific colitis, and pervasive developmental disorder in children. Lancet 1998;351:637-41.

5.    Peltola H, Patja A, Leinikki P, Valle M, Davidkin I, Paunio M. No evidence for measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine-associated inflammatory bowel disease or autism in a 14-year prospective study. Lancet 1998;351:1327-8.

6.    Madsen KM. Hviid A, Vestergaard M, et al. A population-based study of measles, mumps, and rubella vaccination and autism. N Engl J Med 2002;347:1477-82.

7.    Dales L, Hammer SJ, Smith NJ. Time trends in autism and in MMR immunization coverage in California. JAMA 2001;285:1183-5.

8.    Kaye JA, del Mar Melero-Montes M, Jick H. Mumps, measles and rubella vaccine and the incidence of autism recorded by general practitioners: A time trend analysis. BMJ 2001;322:460-3.

9.    Taylor B, Miller E, Lingam R, Andrews N, Simmons A, Stowe J. Measles, mumps and rubella vaccination and bowel problems or developmental regression in children with autism: Population study. BMJ 2002;324:393-6.

10.   Institute of Medicine, National Academy of Sciences. Immunization Safety Review: Vaccines and Autism. Washington DC: National Academy Press, 2004.

11.   Demicheli V, Jefferson T, Rivetti A, Price D. Vaccines for measles, mumps and rubella in children. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2005;(4):CD004407.

12.   Uhlmann V, Martin CM, Sheils O, et al. Potential viral pathogenic mechanism for new variant inflammatory bowel disease. Mol Pathol 2002;55:84-90.

13.   Martin CM, Uhlmann V, Killalea A, Sheils O, O’Leary JJ. Detection of measles virus in children with ileo-colonic lymphoid nodular hyperplasia, enterocolitis and developmental disorder. Mol Psychiatry 2002;7 Suppl 2:S47-8.

14.   Kawashima H, Mori T, Kashiwagi Y, Takekuma K, Hoshika A, Wakefield A. Detection and sequencing of measles virus from peripheral mononuclear cells from patients with inflammatory bowel disease and autism. Dig Dis Sci 2000;45:723-9.

15.   D’Souza Y, Fombonne E, Ward BJ. No evidence of persisting measles virus in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from children with autism spectrum disorder. Pediatrics 2006;118:1664-75. (Erratum in 2006;118:2608).

16.   Singh VK, Jensen RL. Elevated levels of measles antibodies in children with autism. Pediatr Neurol 2003;28:292-4.

17.   Murch SH, Anthony A, Casson DH, et al. Retraction of an interpretation. Lancet 2004;363:750.

18.   Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Thimerosal in vaccines: A joint statement of the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Public Health Service. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 1999;48:563-5.

19.   Verstraeten T, Davis RL, DeStefano F, et al. Safety of thimerosal-containing vaccines: A two-phased study of computerized health maintenance organization databases. Pediatrics 2003;112:1039-48. (Erratum in 2004;113:184).

20.   Hviid A, Stellfeld M, Wohlfahrt J, Melbye M. Association between thimerosal-containing vaccine and autism. JAMA 2003;290:1763-6.

21.   Andrews N, Miller E, Grant A, Stowe J, Osborne V, Taylor B. Thimerosal exposure in infants and developmental disorders: A retrospective cohort study in the United Kingdom does not support a causal association. Pediatrics 2004;114:584-91.

22.   Heron J, Golding J, ALSPAC Study Team. Thimerosal exposure in infants and developmental disorders: A prospective cohort study in the United Kingdom does not support a causal association.

23.   Madsen KM, Lauritsen MB, Pedersen CB, et al. Thimerosal and the occurrence of autism: Negative ecological evidence from Danish population-based data. Pediatrics 2003;112:604-6.

24.   Parker SK, Schwartz B, Todd J, Pickering LK. Thimerosalcontaining vaccines and autistic spectrum disorder: A critical review of published original data. Pediatrics 2004;114:793-804. Pediatrics. (Erratum in 2005;115:200).

25.   Fombonne E, Zakarian R, Bennett A, Meng L, McLean-Heywood D. Pervasive developmental disorders in Montreal, Quebec, Canada: Prevalence and links with immunizations. Pediatrics 2006;118:e139-50.

26.   California Department of Developmental Services. Autism <http://www.dds.ca.gov/Autism/Autism_main.cfm> (Version current at April 17, 2007 ).

27.   The Autism Genome Project Consortium; Szatmari P, Paterson AD, Zwaigenbaum L, et al. Mapping autism risk loci using genetic linkage and chromosomal rearrangements. Nat Genet 2007;39:319-28.

= = = = = = = = = = = =

E.  FROM SHIV, FOREIGN PROTEIN CONSTITUENTS IN VACCINES LEAD TO THE VARIOUS DISEASES (MORE THAN THE MERCURY, ALUMINUM)

Bear in mind that more than mercury, aluminium, and other toxic materials it is the foreign protein constituents in vaccines that lead to various auto-immune diseases, such as autism and other afflictions.

Shiv Chopra, Author,

CORRUPT TO THE CORE: Memoirs of a Health Canada Whistleblower

www.shivchopra.com

= = = = = == = = = = = =

(12) WHAT TO DO RE SWINE FLU

A. A FOOD SYSTEM THAT KILLS, THE ROLE OF “FACTORY FARMS” IN THE EVOLUTION OF SWINE AND BIRD (AVIAN) FLU.  REMEMBER ALL THOSE CHICKENS THAT WERE KILLED IN B.C.?

http://www.grain.org/articles/?id=48

Also, a fact sheet at:

http://www.beyondfactoryfarming.org/files/swineflu.pdf

B. SIMPLE STEPS

(attributed to Dr. Vinay Goyal,  MBBS,DRM,DNB (Intensivist and Thyroid specialist), having clinical experience of over 20 years.  He has worked in institutions like Hinduja Hospital, Bombay Hospital, Saifee Hospital, Tata Memorial, etc.  Presently, he is heading our Nuclear Medicine Department and Thyroid clinic at Riddhivinayak Cardiac and Critical Centre, Malad (W).

Also attributed to “Dr. Oz”.

The only portals of entry are the nostrils and mouth/throat. In a global epidemic of this nature, it’s almost impossible to avoid coming into contact with H1N1 in spite of all precautions. Contact with H1N1 is not so much of a problem as proliferation is.

While-you are still healthy and not showing any symptoms of H1N1 infection, in order to prevent proliferation, aggravation of symptoms and development of secondary infections, some very simple steps, not fully highlighted in most official communications, can be practiced (instead of focusing on how to stock N95 or Tamiflu):

1. Frequent hand-washing (well highlighted in all official communications).

2. “Hands-off-the-face” approach. Resist all temptations to touch any part of face (unless you want to eat or bathe.)

3.*Gargle twice a day with warm salt water (use Listerine or Hydrogen Peroxide if you don’t trust salt).  *H1N1 takes 2-3 days after initial infection in the throat/ nasal cavity to proliferate and show characteristic symptoms. Simple gargling prevents proliferation. In away, gargling with salt water has the same effect on a healthyindividual that Tamiflu has on an infected one. Don’t underestimatethis simple, inexpensive and powerful preventative method.

4.Similar to 3 above, *clean your nostrils at least once every day with warm salt water, or hydrogen peroxide. *Not everybody may be good atJala Neti or Sutra Neti (very good Yoga asanas to clean nasalcavities), but *blowing the nose softly once a day and swabbing bothnostrils with cotton buds dipped in warm salt water is very effectivein bringing down viral population.*

5.*Boost your natural immunity with foods that are rich in Vitamin C (Amla and other citrus fruits). *If you have to supplement with VitaminC tablets, make sure that it also has Zinc to boost absorption.

6.*Drink as much of warm liquids (tea, coffee, etc) as you can. *Drinking warm liquids has the same effect as gargling, but in the reverse direction. They wash off proliferating viruses from the throat into the stomach where they cannot survive, proliferate or do any harm.

– – – – – – –  —  — –

C.  FROM DENIS HALL, BE PRO-ACTIVE

“Remedial Health Care Folks” are physicians, surgeons, dentists, physio therapists, nurses, technicians, hospital administrators, etc. who have vested interests in people being sick.   The health care people make lots of money when people/patients buy into the delusion that they – the remedial health-care people – can fix what people/patients have let go wrong with themselves.   Other than for accidents and inherited disorders, some authorities estimate that at least 80% of patients in our health-care systems have let themselves get sick because they wrongly think the health-care system can remediate their health status.

Each of us must be pro-active and look after ourselves.  Either that or become victims of the health care system full of endless referrals, line ups, hospital stays, and prescriptions like we have no other life and as if the public purse is bottomless.

The current H1N1 flu pandemic scare is an excellent example of the need for each person to be pro-active about their own personal health care.  Each of us needs to make sure that we make our own personal fitness a priority so that when illness, injury, emergency or in this case a pandemic strikes, our body is equipped and prepared to fight.

In this vein of thinking, a priority first step is to immediately institute quality and compulsory daily physical education and health programs in schools, and to have such programs headed by degreed physical education and health-care educators.  Parents and students should be hounding educational leaders including school trustees, administrators and Ministry of Education officials in this regard.

Denis Hall

Retired Teacher/Principal

Director, YAS Sports Schools Inc.

Active Men’s Plus Member, Saskatoon YMCA

(Denis:  thanks.  May I add specifically also that ” health-care educators” need to somehow teach so effectively that young people WANT to change their diets?  Sugar-laden drinks and artificial food weaken the immune system.)

= = = = = = = = ==  = = = = = ==

(13)  AT THE UNIVERSITY: IT’S NOT INNOVATION, IT’S HYPED STATUS QUO.

It is natural that we have different view-points; our experiences are different.

However, finding “the truth” as far as it can be known, is very difficult in a world where corporate interests buy science, administrators and government regulators.  All of whom would deny the charge, I suppose!  Never mind there is ample evidence to support my statement.

I do not have trust in “the authorities” because too many of them are products of a system that has lost its curiosity. People are obedient to the status quo because that is where the money is.  The money is coming from drug lords, the pharmaceutical corporations.

Disease rates are going higher (diabetes, cancer, obesity, autoimmune disease, now tuberculosis (recent reports of TB in First Nations communities in Manitoba), and so on.  “The medicare system” has got to be challenged.  Numbers of people are doing that, Dr. Marcia Angell, the Union of Concerned Scientists, Dr. Shiv Chopra, etc.

If the system takes more and more money but doesn’t deliver results there is something very wrong. An old theme of mine:  the medicare system should be evaluated in terms of health outcomes.  The incidence of diabetes should be going down, not up. The incidence of Multiple Sclerosis and Parkinson’s Disease should be going down. The incidence of cancer (the number of people who get cancer) should be going down, not up – – and it would be, if we took three-quarters of the money out of drug “innovation” and did true innovation to get rid of known carcinogens and teratogens, etc.

“Innovation” is heralded as more drugs or more chemicals or more gmo’s or more industry money in universities and more vaccinations. That is not innovation; it is maintenance of “business as usual”, the status quo.  It is only hyped as innovation.

There is a serious and unacceptable undermining of “science”.  Large corporate interests “buy” science and they buy government regulators.  We have seen example after example.  There are court convictions.

These known-to-be-corrupt corporations buy their way into the universities where they debase the knowledge base.  We come to the point where you don’t know which “science” to trust.

There are very good people doing very good work.  We need to get rid of the bad apples and change the system.  The Governments need to fund the universities; it is not their (our) business to fund the corporations.  We need to be able to trust science.

Values lie at the base of the de-basing.

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = =  ==

(14)  “INTRODUCTION” AT THE END.  SUMMARY.

I can’t thank you enough for the thoughtful input on H1N1 (response to email sent Oct 7th). I hope I have not missed any of it.

It is a challenge to find “the truth”.  I leave it to you to find yours.  I hope this will be helpful to some.

My view-point on H1N1 and healthcare is influenced by my experience with another contagious disease.  I was diagnosed with an active case of tuberculosis 4 or 5 years ago, BUT in an early stage BEFORE it became contagious. I was curious, experimented and learned a lot.

Before my experience with tuberculosis, and after, we have circulated information on various cases of the terrible harm done knowingly by pharmaceutical corporations (Big Pharma).

The laws that create corporations are badly in need of change; they are our laws, we are the responsible parties. The changes will be welcomed by us, and by many in the corporate world.  It is not as though individual employees all like their corporate behavior; it is a way of making a living (not to deny the sometimes role of greed and lack of ethics (courage)!). The system is improperly structured; it does not serve the needs of our society. And so it will be changed.

My statements regarding the pharmaceutical industry are based on a cumulative history that is in the public record.  You cannot divorce their deeds and values from their money.

This email demonstrates that the university-corporate “partnerships” (in general and specifically in medicine and pharmacy in this example) are a wrong-headed approach that citizens need to change.

We are the enablers of the corporate takeover of the universities (if this is a democracy); and we are the funders in ways most of us do not know about.

Citizens are mobilizing to re-assert their set of values on their publicly-owned institutions.  Hallelujah!  There is hope!

/Sandra

Nov 182009
 

http://www.thesheaf.com/opinions/2009/11/18/look-before-you-leap/

by on November 18, 2009 in Opinions

MARY JEAN HANDE
Opinions Writer

Many of you have probably heard about the potential development of nuclear power in Saskatchewan.

After an extensive province-wide consultation process this summer, conducted by the Uranium Development Partnership Committee, an overwhelming 84 per cent of Saskatchewan citizens opposed the reactor. Most people opposed the creation of dangerous nuclear waste, the disposal of nuclear waste in our province and the high costs of nuclear power. They expressed interest in developing more renewable forms of energy.
Nuclear Reactor
While it is clear that the vocal majority in Saskatchewan are not in favour of nuclear development, there seem to be mixed feelings about a research reactor or commercial isotope production here on the University of Saskatchewan campus.

A lot of the interest has to do with our government. Brad Wall wants to go full speed ahead with nuclear development despite public opposition and, indeed, despite what the UDP (a committee created by his own government) recommended. He got his foot in the door even before the consultation process was completed. How? By submitting a proposal to the federal government for a research reactor, using the global isotope shortage as an excuse.

The UDP clearly states that the main purpose for a research reactor on campus would be to train personnel for a large-scale, power generating nuclear reactor. The question must then be posed: if the main purpose of building a research reactor is to train people to work at a nuclear power reactor, and yet we don’t want a Canada Deuterium Uranium reactor, why would we build one?

Furthermore, the UDP discourages the construction of a research reactor for isotope production because isotope production cannot generate enough money to justify the construction of the facility.

In other words, it is completely economically inviable.

One could conclude that the U of S would have to pick up the tab.

There are already tongues wagging on campus about the ever-increasing operating budget of the synchrotron and the impact its cost is having on other academic programs. To make things worse, by the time a nuclear facility is up and running for isotope production, the isotope crisis will be over.

If the government and university were really serious about cost effectiveness and timely production of medical isotopes they would be looking at a particle accelerator (such as the one proposed by the Tri-University Meson Facility at the University of British Columbia) instead of a nuclear reactor facility. However, it looks like Brad Wall has been able to cloud the issue by capitalizing on public concern about the medical isotope crisis.

Another reason why people seem to be in favour of a research reactor, as opposed to a Canada Deuterium Uranium reactor, is because they believe that it will attract leading scholars, scientists and professionals and result in a Nuclear Centre of Excellence for Saskatchewan. Although this is very possible, Shannon Dyck, a student in the School of Environment and Sustainability at the U of S and former USSU executive member, warns that marrying scholarly research with industry has a number of implications for post-secondary education.

However, she points out that since the provincial government and the university are so intent on combining the energy sector with post-secondary education, why not focus on transitioning away from non-renewable energy by placing more resources into renewable energy research?

Saskatchewan’s wind and solar energy capabilities remain vastly underdeveloped and pale in comparison to Germany’s renewable energy sector. To date, windmills in Germany provide power and electricity to 10 million homes and employ over 84,000 people in the renewable industry. Saskatchewan, on the other hand, has even more potential for this kind of renewable production, but harnesses a mere fraction of possible wind power.

The U of S has the opportunity to lead this type of research and development. We should capitalize on that.

Nov 152009
 

Corporatized universities devalue education

Howard Woodhouse

2009/11/15 04:30:00   The Toronto Star

Governments, corporations and most university administrators regard Canadian universities as “engines of economic growth.” Their function is no longer the search for truth, but to increase global competitiveness.

Critical questions about this new orthodoxy are rarely raised. The goal of education, after all, is the advancement and dissemination of shared knowledge, whereas the goal of the corporate market is the maximization of stockholder value. Unless these opposing value systems are recognized, the distinctive features of education are subjugated to the demands of the market.

Some university presidents have expressed skepticism toward the market model of education. Several years ago, Colin Starnes, then president and vice-chancellor of University of King’s College, argued that underfunding by the federal government over a 20-year period (amounting to 30 per cent on a per student basis) combined with increasing student enrollment (more than 60 per cent) had resulted in “a rising tide” engulfing universities.

Two related currents in this tide particularly concerned Starnes: The pressures and benefits of a vastly increased research agenda had, in turn, created a new environment in which undergraduate education was being “privatized” in the form of a dramatic increase in tuition fees. The distinctive features of openness, accessibility and quality were under threat. The net result was that the Canadian university system was becoming much more like that in the United States.

The pace of privatization has since increased, including further increases in tuition fees. The federal government would now have to invest an additional $4 billion a year in universities just to return to the funding levels of the early 1980s.

The Innovation Agenda was first introduced by the Liberal government of Jean Chrétien in the late 1990s. The panel which designed the initial report comprised CEOs of private banks and corporations in addition to the president of the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council. Not a single faculty member was included on the panel of “experts.” The report defined innovation in exclusively economic terms as the overriding need for universities “to bring new goods and services to market.”

As a result, the federal government required universities to produce research that primarily serves the needs of the market. Matching funds for such research must be found from the provinces and the private sector. Universities and provincial governments have been forced to comply with an Innovation Agenda that undermines the institutional autonomy of universities.

The explicit goal of the Innovation Agenda was to have Canada move to fifth place in the world – from its position as 14th – in research support in order to increase economic productivity. But the agenda has failed to achieve its goal. Canada has not moved into the top five countries in the OECD, our capacity to compete in the global market is much the same as it was, and universities remain chronically underfunded.

A reasoned response would be for university presidents to call for a reassessment of the Innovation Agenda together with a large increase in government funding. But the presidents of the so-called “top five” universities (Toronto, British Columbia, Alberta, McGill and Montreal) have done the opposite.

They want a larger share of existing research money and graduate education for themselves. They believe that other universities should focus on undergraduate education, which is seen as a lesser activity. Indeed, University of Toronto president David Naylor has called for more “differentiation” among universities – just the kind of system which Starnes and others have been decrying.

In order to counteract this trend, faculty, students and the general public must remind governments of their responsibility to fund the entire university system as the only place in society where the critical search for knowledge takes precedence.

Howard Woodhouse is professor of educational foundations and co-director of the University of Saskatchewan Process Philosophy Research Unit. His book, Selling Out: Academic Freedom and the Corporate Market, was published by McGill-Queen’s University Press in October.

Nov 082009
 

Twice I set this page up, complete with text.   But when I try to post it to the blog,  it disappears. 

I don’t have time right now to find a different source for the news report.  I found the Japan Times 2009 Soros op-ed by googling ”   No alternative to a new world architecture  “.

Nov 072009
 

Winnipeg Free Press – PRINT EDITION

By: Jen Skerritt

7/11/2009

Aside from improving housing, experts say there are a number of things that would help reduce the number of TB cases:

1) Treat people close to home

Experts such as Dr. Michael Gardam say there’s no reason for infectious TB patients to be flown to urban hospitals from remote communities for treatment. Other provinces, Ontario among them, don’t medevac patients — TB experts in Toronto communicate with nursing station staff via phone and email and help manage TB cases from start to finish.

Gardam’s Toronto clinic has used that model to help communities such as Sioux Lookout. He says it works well in alleviating some of the historical fear associated with the disease. Getting patients started with drug treatment as soon as possible is key, he said, and most infectious patients can stay at home and wear a mask instead of being hospitalized.

The only patients hospitalized at his clinic are difficult drug-resistant cases and patients who are under court order to finish treatment.

“It’s not ideal, but it’s better than shipping them to another community,” said Gardam, the director of infection prevention and control at Toronto’s University Health Network, the country’s largest research hospital.

“Why the hell does someone from Sioux Lookout want to come to Toronto?”

2) Encourage more patients with ‘sleeping’ TB to take medication.

While patients with infectious TB can’t refuse medical treatment since they are a risk to the public, patients with sleeping TB aren’t obligated to complete drug therapy. The drug treatment for both phases of the disease takes months to complete and comes with side-effects.

“That is one of the biggest challenges,” said Dr. William Libich, medical officer with the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority. “Right now, we see contacts that have refused therapy and have gone on to develop TB.”

Doctors don’t know which patients will develop active TB disease. Certain risk factors — HIV and diabetes among them — increase a patient’s likelihood of getting sick from TB. For that reason, researchers are working on a shorter treatment for sleeping TB.

3) Improve TB drugs

Dr. Dick Menzies, director of the respiratory division at the McGill University Health Centre, is testing whether four months of the anti-TB drug rifampin are as effective a treatment for sleeping TB as the drug that must be taken for nine months.

He said shortening the time it takes to complete the medication could help encourage more patients with sleeping TB to take the drugs.

“Even four months (of treatment) isn’t great. It’s a long time,” Menzies said. “It’s hard to get people through a week of antibiotics.”

Because the disease typically manifests itself among marginalized people, Menzies said pharmaceutical companies haven’t taken a keen interest in researching better medications. There is little financial incentive for major drug manufacturers to spend money on research since the vast majority
of the world’s TB patients live in poor, developing countries.

4) Combat racism

University of Saskatchewan TB researcher Paul Hackett said a lot of the problems in First Nations communities, including diseases such as TB and diabetes, are the fallout from decades of failed colonial policies. The problems stem from the federal government forcing First Nations people to abandon their traditions and live on reserves and in residential schools. The repercussions are huge, Hackett said, but he cautioned that government spending is a simple answer to very complicated social problem. He said the province needs to combat racism toward First Nations people if there’s ever going to be a true solution.

Hackett met a man in Cross Lake who spent a lot of time in treatment for TB as a boy after he contracted the disease in a residential school — a traumatic, defining event he suspects many Canadians would tell him “to get over.”

“There’s an undercurrent in the population that says, ‘well, they get free education, free this, free that, they don’t pay taxes and they should stop whining about what happened with the treaties, 100 years or so ago,’ ” he said.

“You’re telling him to get over a defining moment in his life, and yet they wouldn’t say that to other people. They’re very quick to tell people to get over huge issues that aren’t that old.”

jen.skerritt@freepress.mb.ca

Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition November 7, 2009 A9

1 Comment

Posted by: morebs

November 7, 2009 at 8:40 AM

While Mr. Hackett says that it is a “complicated social problem” with “huge repercussions,” the solution he offers is “the province needs to combat racism.” Simple enough solution, don’t you think? Maybe something was lost in the translation.

However, the solution is indeed quite simple… its called EQUALITY. How to achieve it might be more problematic and involve more than a provincial government. A logical starting point is in the “legislated racism” of instruments like the Indian Act, the reserve system, etc. But I submit that pressure for reform must come come from ALL quarters. One’s income, lifestyle, ancestry, religion, housing situation, shoe size, etc., etc. … its all irrelevant. A genuine personal belief in equality is what counts. We can’t, and shouldn’t, continue to blame someone else [like “the government” for instance.]  If one needs to blame someone, then blame can lie with all who don’t promote equality!

Nov 042009
 

CONTENTS

1.  JK ROWLING’S ADDRESS TO HARVARD UNIVERSITY GRADUATING CLASS.  THE VERY BEST GIFT I (SANDRA) CAN GIVE TO YOU.

2.  HOWARD WOODHOUSE’S NEW BOOK RE UNIVERSITIES: “SELLING OUT”.

3.  UNIVERSITIES AND VALUES, AN URGENT PROBLEM FOR US ALL.  WHAT TO DO.

4.  COMMENTARY (BACKGROUND FOR NEWCOMERS)

5.  TWO DIFFERENT SETS OF ETHICS, APPROPRIATE TO THEIR FUNCTION:  GUARDIANSHIP, COMMERCE (from “SYSTEMS OF SURVIVAL”)

 = = = = = = = = = == = = = = = = = = 

1.  JK ROWLING’S ADDRESS TO HARVARD UNIVERSITY GRADUATING CLASS. THE VERY BEST GIFT I (SANDRA) CAN GIVE TO YOU.  EXTRAORDINARY.

JK Rowling – author of the Harry Potter series.  

Part 1 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nkREt4ZB-ck    

Part 2 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9kh_tSiqL1U&feature=related    

Part 3 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LqGotirF20w&NR=1  

(Note:  Harvard University is now the “Harvard Corporation”.)  

= = = = = = = = = == = = = = = 

2. HOWARD WOODHOUSE’S NEW BOOK RE UNIVERSITIES: “SELLING OUT” 

VALUES are a major theme in Rowling’s address to the University graduates.  VALUES at universities are the major theme of Howard Woodhouse’s new book:  “Selling Out: Academic Freedom and the Corporate Market”.  The book has been nominated for a Saskatchewan Book Award. 

” “Selling Out” demonstrates that the logics of value of the market place and of universities are not only different but opposed to one another.  Woodhouse explains how academic freedom and university autonomy are being subordinated to corporate demands and how faculty have attempted to resist this subjugation.  Howard Woodhouse is a professor of educational foundations and co-director of the University of Saskatchewan Process Philosophy Research Unit.”  

You are fortunate if you live in Saskatoon.   You can meet Howard in person at the book launch!  You are invited:  Thursday, November 5th, 7:30, McNally Robinson Bookstore on 8th Street. 

= = = = = = = = = = = = =  = = 

3. UNIVERSITIES AND VALUES, AN URGENT PROBLEM FOR US ALL.  WHAT TO DO. 

Know what our own values are.

And then fight for them. 

What value system does our educational system promote to our young people?  What are the consequences for us, as a society, of the dominant value system? 

Will it be:

(a) JK Rowling’s set of values, or will be it be

(b) the values of the corporations (Howard’s book)?  Nothing matters but making money to send to shareholders.  

We had best know the answer to the question and set things right if there are problems.  Howard’s book makes the case. We will find the ways. 

= = = = = = = = = = = = =  = = 

4.  COMMENTARY (BACKGROUND FOR NEWCOMERS) 

Corporation (noun) – an ingenious device for obtaining profit without individual responsibility. 

But the commerce function in our society is valuable. 

What has happened? … Always, the world changes. Sometimes not for the good. 

Jane Jacobs’ book “Systems of Survival, A Dialogue on the Moral Foundations of Commerce and Politics” tells us that there are two separately evolved codes of ethics for the commerce and for the guardianship (governance, public) functions in a society. The ethics in the two spheres are different because the two spheres serve different purposes.  

When we fail to know and uphold the difference, when we start to use business ethics in the guardianship role and vice versa, guardianship ethics in the business role, there is serious corruption.  Service to the public good is lost. Exactly where we are today – all you have to do is to look at various African countries to see the future of the corruption.  The wealth flows to small numbers of very rich people who have power and control; there are large numbers of impoverished people.

Will it be: 

(1) JK Rowling’s set of values, 

Or will it be 

(2) A takeover of the critical guardianship function by the values of the corporations?  Nothing matters but making money to send to shareholders.  

OR  will it be 

(3) re-drawing the separation between the commercial and guardianship functions in our society? 

We had best know the answer to the question.  

Earlier emails have discussed the opposition between the public good and the corporate good.  An economy is based upon a resource.  If you can own the resource, you get to make all the money.  And if you can pass responsibility for the costs of your operations on to the public purse (the timid and scared little people who work dutifully to pay taxes), you can make exorbitant profits. 

We talked about the profit potential in a “knowledge economy” if the corporations get to own the knowledge resource.  Just like they own oil and gas. And the other energy resources. And just like they would like to own the water resource. 

Commerce can be kept in check only if there is a strong guardianship (government regulatory) function.  We know that from the economic crisis.  Self-regulation absolutely does not work.  

We are taught that in a democracy there must be a separation of powers, checks and balances.  The judicial function must be independent of the political, for obvious safeguard reasons.    

The research and insights of Jane Jacobs take it a step further: the political and governance function must also be independent of the commercial function.  

“Systems of Survival”, a telling title for her book, documents the historical evolution of the different ethics for the two functions.  

The road back to a situation where corporations have respect, is to remove them from government and from the universities.  The government must fund the universities (public interest, guardianship). They must not fund the corporations (private interest, commerce). 

Government and universities overtaken by corporate interests – a loss of the guardianship function – is a form of government known as fascist. 

Imposition of the ethics of commerce on our educational institutions, making them the training grounds for corporations … if you need a reminder about the evils of that, watch “The Sound of Music”.  And note that it is another way (in addition to pollution) of passing the cost of operations (in this case, training) onto the public purse.  Howard’s book, “Selling Out” makes this clear. 

This is our society, our responsibility.  It is our choice to participate in it or not. WE will decide the outcome, through action or through inaction.  It is our choice to be “victims” or not. 

The lessons are all there in the histories of what happened in the lead-up to World War Two.  It is interesting how much of it comes down to people knowing and LIVING their values, being willing to stand up and speak up loud and clear for those values, not only for ourselves but for others, BEFORE it is too late.  If we wait until the assault is directed at us personally, it will be too late.  

Some faculty at the University of Saskatchewan and other Universities are intimidated.  The Department of Agriculture is run by Monsanto, Bayer Crop Science, and other chemical-biotech corporations.  Professors and researchers with an alternate view of agriculture are marginalized and not funded. The corporate good trumps the public good AND the search for truth. 

The uranium and nuclear industry is moving onto the U of S campus big-time now. The petroleum industry is already well established at the University of Regina.  If the corporations have their way, the “small” reactors for tar sands expansion will be developed at the University with disastrous consequences for climate change, for water resources, and for the death by acidification of northern Saskatchewan. The public interest is subverted, no different from what is on-going in the College of Agriculture. 

Students in Veterinary Medicine tell of their repugnance for the biased teachings of a professor who advocates (“sells”) intensive livestock operations.  He receives money from the industry.  His job is to create unquestioning loyalty, not critical thinking or research in the public interest. 

The professors in the university who dissent find themselves in trouble with the administration. Their public-interest work is jeopardized. The knowledge resource of the society is jeopardized.  It will be commodified and “owned” if the corporations and their collaborators have their way.  Education becomes less and less “public” as it evolves to conform with models of profit centres. 

Fascist control with a ruling elite is more easily achieved in a population that is taught not to question.  Howard Woodhouse’s book, “Selling Out” is a gift to us in the effort to take back our universities.  

There is a guarantee that we will not follow the descent into fascism: as always, it is the formation of a critical mass of informed people. All you have to do is to talk with your friends – – introduce the topic into conversations.  

I have great faith that when people have the information, they will have the conversations and when they have the conversations, they will find the remedies.  It will take a while but that’s okay.  

Thank-you Howard Woodhouse, and thank-you JK Rowling.  Ordinary people doing extraordinary things.  We stand behind you. 

= = = = == == = == = = = = = = = 

5.  TWO DIFFERENT SETS OF ETHICS, APPROPRIATE TO THEIR FUNCTION.   (from SYSTEMS OF SURVIVAL

GUARDIANSHIP                                      COMMERCE

shun force                                                        shun trading

voluntary agreement                                  exert prowess

be honest                                                          be obedient and disciplined

collaborate                                                      adhere to tradition

compete                                                           respect hierarchy

respect contracts                                        be loyal

use initiative and enterprise                  take vengeance

open to inventiveness and novelty    deceive for the sake of the task

be efficient                                                     make rich use of leisure

promote comfort and convenience    be ostentatious

dissent for the sake of the task              dispense largesse

invest for productive purposes            be exclusive

be industrious                                              show fortitude

be thrifty                                                         be fatalistic

be optimistic                                                 treasure honor

Nov 032009
 

Winnipeg Free Press – PRINT EDITION

The number of TB cases in Manitoba is on the rise, and the doctor who used to be responsible for keeping the disease in check says the system has developed cracks and people are falling through

By: Jen Skerritt

It’s just six years since Hershfield retired as the longtime director of Manitoba’s tuberculosis-control program, but he’s already watched the system he worked for 37 years to build break down and lose track of patients.

He recently saw a woman in his downtown cityplace medical clinic who’d been prescribed enough TB medication to kill her.

Another woman who came for a checkup had been exposed to infectious TB, but no one did a skin test, chest X-ray or referred her for followup.

He was infuriated when a man with infectious TB recently came to see him — the man hadn’t filled his prescription for TB drugs and was walking around, spreading the disease.

Hershfield has phoned, written and met with some of Manitoba’s most senior medical officials to tell them the province needs what he calls a TB czar, someone to take charge and ensure no cases go undetected.  The 74-year-old offered to re-organize the TB program himself.

So far, he hasn’t received a response.

“You can’t convince them. People who control the money are more interested in West Nile virus that’s going to affect 10 people and kill one out of 3,000,” Hershfield said. “Without a co-ordinated system, without people going out and getting the entire population, you can’t win. “I see that things are falling apart.”

The number of TB cases reported across the province and in Winnipeg is on the rise, yet cases are being missed, health officials admit. The latest provincial disease statistics show the number of TB cases between January and August 2009 increased nearly 25 per cent over the same period last year. Manitoba used to record about 100 cases of TB a year, but the province hit 113 in August and the numbers are still climbing.

Most TB cases are reported in the north and Winnipeg.  Northern health officials in Thompson blame the increase on poor living conditions on many northern reserves. Winnipeg health officials say the numbers are up because they’re doing a better job of finding people with the disease.

Hershfield suspects the reason is cut and dried: The system doesn’t work anymore. TB is out of control. Things have changed since he was at the helm, and privacy laws now ban some of Hershfield’s past unorthodox ways of ensuring his patients took their medication — including training Main Street bartenders to dispense drugs to regulars.

The system to track and treat TB was handed over to regional health authorities, and Hershfield thinks that shift left no one in charge of making sure things work properly.

“Now, there are too many cases,” Hershfield said. “The public health system broke down. It’s now fragmented. Patients are less visible. There isn’t what I call a czar.”

Hershfield’s no-nonsense approach to TB was simple — find cases of TB, put the patients on drugs, watch them take those drugs, track down everyone else they exposed to the airborne bacteria and put them on drugs, too.

He and nurse Joann MacMorran co-ordinated the Manitoba Lung Association’s TB program out of a small office at Health Sciences Centre for more than three decades. Their program kept the number of TB cases relatively stable. Doctors and nurses across the province and on reserves knew
Hershfield was the TB point man and would send him patients with symptoms. New immigrants under surveillance for TB were referred to  Hershfield for followup after they entered the country.

Contacts across Manitoba alerted him when patients didn’t show up to take their pills, and Hershfield had a way to keep track and ensure people took their medication — what is called “directly observed therapy.” Nurses on reserves and in the city met with patients and watched them ingest their pills. The nurses went looking for missing patients when they didn’t show up. Infectious patients who refused to take their medication were
arrested and put in isolation in hospital.

The number of cases a year hovered around 100 from the late 1980s right up until Hershfield’s departure in 2003. His system worked so well that the Canadian Society for International Health asked Hershfield to set up the same program in Guyana.

Hershfield took a tough and sometimes unorthodox approach to finding his patients and getting the job done. He often trained people in the community — including staff in Main Street hotels — to dispense TB drugs to patients. If patients didn’t show up to take their pills, staff would phone Hershfield and MacMorran would scour watering holes in search of the missing patient. Sometimes Hershfield would even troll the  downtown bars himself to hunt for patients.

“We trained the bartender to do it, so the bartender would give him his medication,” he said. “We were concerned about getting the medication into the patient. I didn’t care whether you’re drunk or not, take your medication.”

Things didn’t always go Hershfield’s way.

The outspoken physician wanted better housing for his patients and more money to bolster TB prevention. As far back as 1987, Hershfield warned that treaty natives had a high rate of TB because of poor living conditions. He hit bureaucratic roadblocks and became increasingly frustrated.

“The problem with these kinds of situations is health is a department. Housing is a department. Everybody has their own budget. If I was to say I need more housing on this reserve because of tuberculosis they’d say, ‘meh, we don’t need it there,’ ” Hershfield said.

“Those are the realities. I see patients today who are still in overcrowded houses that 10 years ago I wrote letters about.”

The TB-control program changed when Hershfield retired in 2003.

The program was shuffled to an interim director who resigned a year later. No one was in charge for months until the province took over TB care in April 2006. Several months after that, the province handed the responsibility of finding, diagnosing and treating TB patients to regional health authorities.

Because most TB cases in Manitoba are reported in Thompson and Winnipeg, the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority and Burntwood Regional Health Authority took lead roles in some of the most difficult and time-consuming aspects of TB care — the medical sleuthing in the community to
find patients, getting them to take drugs and rounding up people they’d exposed to TB and putting them on drugs, too.

Dr. Sande Harlos, a WRHA medical officer, remembers the days when the front-desk clerk at Main Street hotels would help administer TB medication, but said the revamped system is more efficient and ensures no one falls through the cracks.

And yet, the TB numbers reported in Winnipeg nearly tripled between 2007 and 2008.

Harlos said there are more public health nurses, and the system no longer relies on proxies — such as bartenders — to keep an eye on TB patients.

Public health nurses now make a point of meeting TB  patients when they are still quarantined on HSC’s sixth-floor isolation unit.  Patients with infectious TB are usually required to stay in the isolation unit for two weeks until drug therapy has kicked in to be sure they can’t spread the
disease to others through coughing or sneezing.

Harlos said the nurse starts building a relationship with the patient early, to make it easier to get the patient to follow through with the entire nine-month drug treatment. Nurses make arrangements and find out the best place for patients to receive their drugs, whether that’s in their homes or a spot in Central Park. The WRHA offers incentives for patients to show up, including sandwiches, bus fare, sometimes even cash.

Even on the isolation ward, infectious patients are given incentives to stay — their TV and phone is paid for and they’re often offered favourite meals. While other jurisdictions have offered cigarettes to TB patients in isolation, medical officer Dr. William Libich said they’ve decided against offering tobacco or alcohol. The idea, he said, is to encourage patients to take a stake in their own health and recovery, although some patients are allowed to go outside to smoke.

“If they’ve rejected offers of nicotine replacement therapy, and they insist on going out (for a smoke) we have to be careful about that,” Libich said. “We don’t want folks leaving isolation and not coming back.”

Some patients slip through the cracks.  Months before double-amputee Brian Sinclair was found dead in a Health Sciences Centre waiting room, the WRHA investigated another critical incident — this time a homeless man with a history of substance abuse who told emergency room staff he believed he “had TB.”  A July 2008 summary of the incident reveals the man initially came to the ER with an unrelated complaint, and a chest X-ray
indicated fluid in the lining of his lung — something that could indicate TB or lung cancer. A follow-up CT scan was done, then the patient was discharged and told he needed a followup appointment. He didn’t go to any of the scheduled appointments.

Three months later, the man showed up at the ER drunk, complaining of shortness of breath, a cough and weight loss. Again, he told ER staff he believed he “had TB.”   ER staff did not heed his concerns, and six months later the patient was admitted with advanced TB and told that his prognosis was “poor.” The report doesn’t say what happened to him.

“I don’t think we’re doing well enough,” said Dr. Joel Kettner, Manitoba’s chief medical officer.

Kettner said he believes doctors initially miss some TB cases because the symptoms — including coughing and night sweats — are similar to other respiratory diseases. Although Manitoba has one of the highest TB rates in the country, Kettner said it is not a mainstream disease and many
doctors would see only a few cases throughout their careers.

“For a well-trained doctor, an experienced doctor, this is a challenge to pick out amongst all those reasons that people come and see a doctor,” Kettner said. “There’s a lot of diseases that have those symptoms. The key (with TB) is those symptoms usually don’t get better.”

Wayne Harper knows what can happen when TB is missed.  He buried his 28-year-old brother, Herman Joseph, two years ago. Wayne, a band
councillor at Garden Hill First Nation, said his brother was living in Winnipeg with his girlfriend when he started getting sick. Wayne said his brother went to HSC’s ER many times, but staff there said he had a bad cold and sent him home repeatedly.

Months later, Herman was so sick his lungs were failing, and there was little doctors could do. Harper said TB “got him” when Herman succumbed to the disease after four days of drug treatment in hospital.

“He lay there, and they just took the (life-support) machine out. Shut it off. Just gone,” Harper said.  “Probably he had that TB maybe for months, and they didn’t treat him. They couldn’t do anything because it was too late.”

jen.skerritt  AT  freepress.mb.ca

Free Press reporter Jen Skerritt received a $20,000 Journalism Award from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research to investigate tuberculosis in Manitoba. The stories, photos, videos and interactive website are the result of months of research and collaboration with the Free Press TB
team.

Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition November 3, 2009 A10

Oct 312009
 

Jen Skerrit, Winnipeg Free Press

October 31, 2009

LAC BROCHET, Man. — It’s minutes before 10 a.m., and Alphonse Denechezhe has just finished his morning spit into a plastic cup.  He puts it next to the others on a wooden shelf in the living room, near where his young son and daughter are sleeping on mattresses.  Denechezhe, 42, will take the samples to the nurse, but it could be weeks before anyone knows whether his recent coughing fits and night sweats are what he fears.

Denechezhe calls it “the sickness,” the disease that just won’t go away.   He’s watched tuberculosis devastate his family and plague his community for years.

Northlands First Nation in Lac Brochet, one of Manitoba’s most remote communities, has earned a dubious distinction as a global TB hot spot. It and another Manitoba community health officials will not name recorded the highest rates of TB in the world for two decades. Until 2004, Lac Brochet remained one of the world’s worst-affected communities.

More than a decade ago, Denechezhe watched his ex-wife nearly die of TB of the brain in a Winnipeg hospital isolation room. He and all 18 people who lived in the same three-bedroom house tested positive for TB, too. He was supposed to wear a mask and take medication for nine months to cure his “sleeping TB.”

But Denechezhe doesn’t trust medication, not even Tylenol. He stopped taking the TB pills when he couldn’t handle the intense side effects of nausea and fatigue. He failed to finish his medication again two years ago, after a nurse warned him the disease could strike at any time.

Now, he’s been coughing for weeks and worries he’s already infected his young son who started coughing days go.

“Maybe it’ll kill me. I don’t know,” said Denechezhe. “But this sickness seems to be carrying on. We get rid of it for a little while, but it seems to pop up left and right.”

It’s been more than three decades since the last sanatorium in Manitoba shut its doors and tuberculosis faded in the minds of most of the public.

But TB never went away. It is still rampant in First Nation communities in northern Manitoba. It’s a medical illness propagated by non-medical factors, tangled in a historical and political web that has long neglected the poverty that helps TB survive.

TB is a barometer for overall health: where there is poverty and suffering, there is TB. Plain and simple, it is a symptom of poverty, a byproduct of overcrowded homes, malnutrition and poor overall health.

That same deadly mix let H1N1 flourish in the north this summer and made TB a scourge on Manitoba reserves for a century.

Medical experts warned for years that a major problem would arise in the North if TB outbreaks and the living conditions that contribute to them were not addressed. The warning went unheeded, and the disease exploded in places such as Lac Brochet five years ago. Now, Manitoba has one of the highest TB rates in the country.

In northern Manitoba, living conditions on some reserves are often described as Third World – many houses are decrepit, some don’t have toilets or running water, and multiple families are crammed under one roof.   Inadequate hygiene, rotting walls and close quarters make reserves ripe for the
spread of an airborne disease. When one person gets sick, everybody gets sick.

In 1937, TB officials noted that overcrowded homes and poor living conditions on reserves contributed to the high rate of disease among First Nations. In 2009, as many as 18 people are crammed into three-bedroom houses at Lac Brochet.

The community recorded some of the highest TB rates in the world – more than 600 cases per 100,000, more than 100 times what it should be. By comparison, the national rate in Canada is five cases per 100,000. In developing countries such as Bangladesh, the rate is slightly below 400 cases
per 100,000.

Last year, the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs petitioned Canada’s auditor general to investigate what federal health officials are doing to control the rising rates of infectious diseases such as TB on reserves. Grand Chief Ron Evans hasn’t heard back. He has no idea how many cases of TB surface on reserves because federal and provincial health officials refuse to divulge that information, citing privacy reasons. Evans said they can’t solve
the problem until they have all the facts.

“My suspicions are if they provide that information, it will be so alarming they would have to put resources toward the root causes, which is of course overcrowding, issues of poverty, the lack of proper running water and sewage,” he said.

Manitoba officials refused to disclose the number of cases on reserves, saying to do so would “harm relations” with the federal government.

“It’s an excuse they’re using to cover up inadequacies,” said Dr. Earl Hershfield, former director of the province’s TB control program.

Lac Brochet’s Dene community lives in one of the most remote places in Manitoba – the northwestern corner of the province. A group of families broke away from Brochet to settle in Lac Brochet in the early 1970s.   Northlands First Nation was to be a remote haven where the Dene could hunt caribou, fish and live off the land. The isolation was supposed to preserve their traditional ways of life. Instead, it exacerbated a flurry of health and social problems in recent years.

Few people have jobs, and there’s no way off the reserve except to fly out for a medical appointment or brave the 13-hour, white-knuckle ride on the winter road to Thompson, Man.

Denechezhe said people are cooped up in cramped quarters during the long winter, an invitation for TB to spread.

“It’s just frustrating sometimes to even talk about it, and the more you talk about it the angrier you get,” he said.

In 2001, Indian and Northern Affairs estimated there was a shortfall of 8,500 houses on northern reserves such as Denechezhe’s and close to half of existing homes required renovations. Since then, the shortage has worsened, largely due to limited construction and a birthrate twice the Canadian average.

The reserve baby boom has left many young families homeless. In Lac Brochet, close to 1,000 residents live in 135 houses. People such as Denechezhe are among the hidden homeless who crowd into relatives’ homes because they have nowhere else to stay.

He and two of his children live in his mother’s two-bedroom house with five other family members. The grey house looks nearly identical to the other dozen sandwiched close together in “central” Lac Brochet on a slope near the lake. The two bedrooms and one bathroom are the only divided rooms in the house, and there is little room left for people and furniture in the small space.

“I’m 42 years old, and I’m still living with my mom. It’s not supposed to be like that,” said Denechezhe, who works in the band office.

Half of Lac Brochet houses were included in a recent study and nearly half of those housed at least one person who had contracted TB.  Most of the houses are overcrowded, with an average of eight people per household – four times the Canadian average.

“Size matters,” said Linda Larcombe, an anthropologist and disease researcher with the University of Manitoba who studies the spread of diseases in First Nations.

“It makes sense that (in) a smaller home with more people in it, your risk of contracting airborne and aerosolized disease is going to increase.”

More than half the houses studied had visible mould.  Medical experts say it takes a strong immune response to ward off TB germs, so an individual whose immune system is busy battling the effects of mould may not be able to fight off TB as well.

According to a 2003 auditor general report, many on-reserves houses have mould problems due to improper maintenance, poor ventilation and construction and overcrowding. Some Lac Brochet houses have so much mould they are literally decaying from the inside.

Indian Affairs did not respond to repeated requests for an interview, but sent an e-mail statement saying it will spend about $75 million to improve on-reserve housing in the next two years, part of the economic stimulus package.

Northlands First Nation Chief Joe Dantouze said the problem hasn’t been solved and the community doesn’t have enough money to build new houses or repair others also rotten with mould. That draws criticism from some residents who claim houses are allotted based entirely on a social pecking order.

In Lac Brochet, residents refer to the area where the chief and a lucky few live as Beverly Hills, a row of bi-level houses atop a ridge overlooking the centre of town. Everywhere else, families crowd into small houses with two or three bedrooms and no basements.

Martin St. Pierre shines a flashlight in the crawl space under Stephen Tssessaze’s house to illuminate a black wall so corroded by mould it’s soft to the touch. The beam of light uncovers a patch of long, white mushrooms growing from a crack in the foundation. Thin strips of last year’s withered, slimy mushrooms appear to drip down the putrid wall.

St. Pierre does plumbing work for the band in Lac Brochet. He said he sees too many houses that should be condemned – including others just like this one on the west side of town. Here, St. Pierre said, houses are in a low-lying area where spring run-off drains into the crawl space where moisture gets trapped.

The gag-inducing sight of patches of fungi and pervasive rot is overwhelming, even for St. Pierre.

“When I come through a house like this and there’s kids in there, you feel bad, you know?” St. Pierre said.

Tssessaze lives with his two young boys and his girlfriend. The pungent stench of damp decay is unmistakable. It fills your nostrils when you walk through the front door. Tssessaze said his kids get sick a lot and he often has trouble breathing. He peers at the white fungi in the underbelly of his house, before a solemn look envelops his face.

“It’s too much, right?”

jen.skerritt  AT  freepress.mb.ca

© Copyright (c) Canwest News Service

Oct 212009
 

Dr. Woollard sometimes visits Saskatoon because he is on the accreditation committee for University Medical Schools.  I had a conversation with him about adding his weight to the nuclear battle in Saskatchewan.  He was willing.  Unfortunately I never followed through on coordinating his efforts with ours.  There is a link to a recommended document …   /Sandra

Fri, 16 Oct 2009

Dear Dr Woollard, 

Is it possible to obtain from you the critical pieces of documentation that were used to establish the moratorium on uranium mining in B.C.? 

I am from Saskatoon.  

We are fighting to stop the uranium/nuclear industry / Government of Saskatchewan agenda for:

– expansion of uranium mining & exploration

– nuclear power production

– the siting of radioactive waste disposal in Saskatchewan (for the whole continent I would say)

– the entrenchment of the “Canadian Nuclear Studies Centre” at the U of Sask. 

Last evening (in Vancouver) I gave a talk on the “Canada – U.S. Western Energy Corridor”, tar sands expansion, nuclear energy development and the privatization and export of Canadian energy resources. 

The host was the World Federalist Movement monthly meeting.  

An older woman told me about your work.  As I understand you were almost single-handedly responsible for getting the moratorium on uranium mining in B.C. , the moratorium is significantly based on health effects and that the evidence you used was largely from the uranium mining in Saskatchewan. 

I will be back in Saskatoon in a week or so. 

Thank-you for your consideration. 

Best wishes,

Sandra Finley 

REPLY FROM DR. WOOLLARD

10/21/2009     Please accept my apologies for the delay in responding. I have been travelling to get to work here in Nepal and have been challenged with connections. This is likely to get worse again in the next few days so let me propose a plan.

Thank you for your interest and for your willingness to fight on behalf of your  communities. At present I am working in Nepal and will be back in Vancouver at the end of the month. I wonder if the best plan might be to link up by phone when I get back so we could talk for a half hour or so and delineate the material that would be of greatest value to you. I am copying my assistant Paul Kendal and if this plan works for you perhaps you can let him know and we can arrange a time at your convenience. From there we can see how I can best be of assistance-the intervening 30 years have not diminished my concerns about the potential impact of this industry, nor does it seem there have been significant technologic or regulatory changes sufficient to make it any safer.
I look forward to talking to you on my return to Canada.
Cheers,
Bob Woollard

Robert F Woollard, MD, CCFP, FCFP
Professor
UBC Department of Family Practice
Suite 300, 5950 University Boulevard
Vancouver, BC Canada V6T 1Z3
Tel: 604  827  4753
= = = = = = = =

EMAIL THREAD, DR DALE DEWAR AND MYSELF:

Thanks for your input Dale.   I had a long telephone conversation with Bob.  Need to get back to him with update.  He comes to Saskatoon periodically becuz he is on accreditation body for med school.  He has some good ideas for how to go about “creating waves”.   Bit I am short of time on my end of things! 

I hope you are enjoying holiday rest and re-generation.

Sandra

From: Dale Dewar    Sent: November 11, 2009 2:26 PM
To: Sandra Finley
Cc: JimX Harding; Karen. Weingeist; Cathy. NUKES Holtslander; ValNUKE Drummond; MichelleNUKE Blanchette; MarkNuke Bigland-Pritchard; KarenNUKE Pedersen; JudyNUKE Schachtel; VirginiaNUKE Scissons; Larissa. NUKETOrgFVCExec Shasko; Jim. S & Marion Penna; StefaniaNLS Fortugno; EleanorNUKE Knight; Elaine. FVCExecTOrg Hughes; DarcyNUKE Hande
Subject: Re: Uranium mining, the fellow behind the B.C. moratorium 

Sandra, 

I trust that someone has been able to take you up on this.  Bob Woollard is a marvelous guy – besides haven written the policy piece for nuclear power and uranium mining in the 1980’s for the British Columbia Medical Association – which has “stuck” all these years AND also behind the BC moratorium, he was a founding board member of Canadian Doctors for Medicare, former head of the Department of Family Practice.  He was in Nepal as part of his commitment to education for health care.  He’s a guy who knows when to make small waves that magnify as they move. 

Best wishes 

Dale Dewar, MD, FCFP

Executive Director, 

Physicians for Global Survival

www.pgs.ca 

– – – – – – – – – – – 

On 5-Nov-09, at 4:30 PM, Sandra Finley wrote: 

Oh goodness – I am in over my head.   Maybe I should learn to keep my mouth shut.  I need your input (aside from ”close your mouth”): 

While in B.C. I asked who was behind the B.C. uranium moratorium? 

The answer is  Dr. Bob Woollard, Professor UBC Department of Family Practice. 

I was told that the data he used to get the moratorium was Saskatchewan based. 

I googled and then sent an email to Bob  – he was in Nepal.  He is more than willing to help  and  “From there we can see how I can best be of assistance”  

 Bob’s assistant, Paul Kendal, is in contact to set up the telephone call.

Which is lovely except that I know VERY LITTLE about uranium mining, health and moratoriums, and what we want to do on this front.  I am a little panicked! 

They supplied a link (below) to the document that was a major factor in getting the moratorium, as I understand.  But I haven’t read it. 

I don’t think we have a specific group in Clean Green that is focused on a moratorium on expanded mining of uranium? 

I don’t think we have an actual strategy on this?   

How do you want to move forward on this one? 

Sandra 

YOU MIGHT WANT TO READ FROM BOTTOM UP 

From: Kendal, Paul    Sent: Thu Nov 05, 2009
To: Woollard, Robert; Finley, Sandra
Subject: RE: Uranium mining moratorium 

Good morning Sandra,

I’m writing to see if you’re back yet so we can schedule a call with you and Bob.  Please let me know either by email or at 604  827  4753.

Thanks,   Paul 

FIRST EMAIL FROM PAUL:

If you could please let me know what time of day is best for a phone call, we can work to set aside some time for the two of you to speak.  For now, in case you have not yet seen it, a summary of the BCMA report is available here  (http://www.ccnr.org/bcma.html).

Thanks,

Paul

……………………………………………………….
Paul Kendal
Administrative Coordinator
Rural Coordination Centre of BC (RCCbc)
David Strangway Building, UBC
#300 – 5950 University Blvd
Vancouver BC  V6T 1Z3
 
t:  604 827  4753